Entertainment news and discussion on TalkFuse.
The band The Edge said was better than most rock and roll: “I’ve been thinking for a long time”
The Edge said working with will.i.am on U2’s 2009 album *No Line on the Horizon* was a joy, praising his instincts and the fresh perspective he brought to the sessions. He argued that hip hop and R&B production had become more innovative than rock production, making the collaboration a chance for the band to learn from another style.
The album followed abandoned sessions with Rick Rubin and recording work with Brian Eno and Daniel Lanois, but was later viewed by some in the band as a disappointment. Will.i.am contributed keys to “Magnificent” and “I’ll Go Crazy If I Don’t Go Crazy Tonight”; The Edge said he quickly improved the demo of the latter and highlighted his sense of rhythm.
In short
- The Edge praised will.i.am’s work with U2.
- He contributed to two tracks on the 2009 album.
- The collaboration brought a different production perspective.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The Edge’s case is that working with a producer from hip hop and R&B could refresh U2’s creative habits. He felt will.i.am brought strong rhythmic instincts and a different perspective, and that those genres were then pushing production forward in ways rock could learn from.
The case against
A sceptic could argue that bringing in a producer from another genre does not necessarily make a rock album more effective, and that stylistic novelty can sit uneasily with a band’s established sound. The album’s later reputation as a disappointment to some in U2 may support doubts about whether the collaboration improved the finished record.