World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
The “best” band Josh Homme thought would never be famous
Josh Homme praised Creedence Clearwater Revival as an exceptional band whose lasting appeal has only grown with time, despite their unassuming image making them seem unlikely candidates for mass fame. The article presents this as evidence that strong songwriting and a distinctive sound can outweigh fashion or scene-driven expectations.
Homme suggested that CCR, led by John Fogerty, looked more like ordinary blue-collar workers than conventional 1960s rock stars. Their success rested on songs including ‘Proud Mary’ and ‘Lookin’ Out My Back Door’, while deeper cuts such as ‘Ramble Tamble’ and ‘Keep On Chooglin’’ showed they were more than a singles act.
In short
- Homme admired CCR’s enduring, unpretentious brilliance.
- CCR seemed unlikely stars but became hugely successful.
- Their catalogue extended well beyond familiar hit singles.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Strong songwriting and a distinctive, authentic musical identity can achieve lasting cultural impact and commercial success regardless of whether artists conform to contemporary rock star imagery or fashion expectations; CCR's enduring appeal and deep catalogue prove that genuine artistic quality is the primary engine of sustained fame.
The case against
Image, cultural timing, and commercial positioning are not secondary to songwriting but integral parts of commercial and critical success; CCR's blue-collar aesthetic and unassuming presentation were ideally suited to 1960s counterculture and amplified their appeal substantially, suggesting that artistry cannot be cleanly separated from context and positioning.
Explained simply
Josh Homme is the guitarist and frontman of Queens of the Stone Age, a prominent rock band. Creedence Clearwater Revival, known as CCR, was a hugely successful rock group from the late 1960s and early 1970s, fronted by John Fogerty.
The band achieved major commercial success with hits including 'Proud Mary' and 'Lookin' Out My Back Door', whilst also producing deeper album tracks such as 'Ramble Tamble' and 'Keep On Chooglin''. Unlike the theatrical rock stars who dominated their era, the members of CCR had an understated appearance, resembling ordinary working men rather than conventional musicians.
CCR's enduring influence in rock music has made them of interest to musicians and critics studying musical longevity. Their success across decades, combined with their distinctive image and sound, makes them frequently referenced in discussions about rock music's development and what contributes to lasting artistic impact.
Americas Art Celebrity Culture Entertainment Music World