World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
The CIA and Mossad’s only path to regime change in Iran
The article argues that the CIA and Mossad should support regime change in Iran, presenting the rebuilding of SAVAK, the former imperial security service, as the only viable path. Its author frames the 1979 revolution as a national betrayal and says Western governments failed an ally by allowing the Islamic Republic to take power.
The piece centres on the author’s 2011 book, based on research into SAVAK and conversations with former official Parviz Sabeti, and the backlash the author says followed its publication. It also claims the Soviet Union sought to bring down Iran’s pro-Western monarchy and portrays Iran’s current rulers as aligned with Russia and China. The supplied text does not explain how SAVAK could be rebuilt or provide evidence for these claims.
In short
- The author calls for rebuilding SAVAK to pursue regime change.
- The article condemns the 1979 Iranian revolution.
- It offers no practical plan for rebuilding the security service.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Supporters of backing regime change could argue that Iran’s rulers repress dissent and threaten regional security, so helping Iranians achieve a different government may serve both human rights and Western security. They might view the monarchy’s fall as a strategic loss and see a reformed security service as one possible way to weaken the regime, provided it is accountable and protects civilians.
The case against
Opponents could argue that rebuilding SAVAK risks restoring an organisation associated with repression, undermining the rights and legitimacy that regime change is meant to advance. Foreign intelligence agencies trying to shape Iran’s government could provoke instability, strengthen hardliners and repeat the damage of outside intervention; the article, as described, offers no clear plan or evidence that this approach would work.
Americas Middle East Politics World