New releases, music videos and album news — indie, rap, rock and pop. Always covering Ren, Chris Webby, Sam Tompkins, bbno$, CHINCHILLA, Muse, Yungblud and more.
The drummer Jack Black and Dave Grohl both agreed was even better than John Bonham
John Bonham is widely praised for shaping Led Zeppelin’s sound with powerful, precise drumming, and Dave Grohl has said few players have come close to him. Yet Jack Black chose Keith Moon as the better drummer, while Grohl has spoken warmly of Moon’s distinctive, high-energy style.
Black said Moon’s unpredictability and wildness set him apart, and Grohl described him as playing “like he was on fire”. The article contrasts Bonham’s weight and control, which helped make Zeppelin’s riffs feel immense, with Moon’s restless, chaotic playing, which helped define The Who’s sound. It argues that the comparison depends on what each band needed from its drummer.
In short
- Jack Black picked Keith Moon over John Bonham.
- Dave Grohl praised Moon’s fiery, frantic style.
- Bonham and Moon shaped very different band sounds.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Keith Moon can be considered the better drummer because his restless, explosive style gave The Who a distinctive sound and matched the band’s high-energy music. His unpredictability and willingness to push beyond conventional timekeeping made him an unusually expressive and influential player.
The case against
John Bonham can be considered the better drummer for his powerful, precise playing, which gave Led Zeppelin’s music weight while keeping its complex rhythms controlled. His combination of force and discipline shaped the band’s sound and makes a strong case for judging greatness by command as well as energy.
Explained simply
John Bonham was the drummer in Led Zeppelin, the British rock band known for heavy guitar riffs and songs such as “Whole Lotta Love”. Keith Moon played drums for The Who, another major British rock band, whose music often had a more restless, explosive feel.
Dave Grohl is a drummer and singer best known for Nirvana and Foo Fighters; Jack Black is an actor and musician. Bonham was admired for powerful, controlled playing, while Moon was known for a more unpredictable style that helped shape The Who’s sound.
The comparison matters because drummers can shape a band’s music in very different ways. Whether one player is “better” depends partly on what a listener values and what the band’s songs call for.
Culture Fashion Music Space Technology