Entertainment news and discussion on TalkFuse.
‘The Fantasticks’ Review: A Welcome Broadway Debut Seven Decades In The Making
The Fantasticks has opened on Broadway for the first time, nearly 70 years after the musical became a defining success of Off Broadway. Director Christopher Gattelli gives its story a new perspective by recasting the young lovers as two boys and their feuding parents as mothers, while keeping the show’s gentle, whimsical character.
Maxim Chlumecky and Nathan Levy play the couple, with Zane Phillips making his Broadway debut as El Gallo; Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer and Ruthie Ann Miles play the mothers. The production retains songs including “Try to Remember” and “Soon It’s Gonna Rain”, with new orchestration, though the review says the contrived second act drags. The original production ran Off Broadway for 42 years.
In short
- The Fantasticks makes its Broadway debut after nearly seven decades.
- The revival reimagines its young lovers as two boys.
- The review praises the cast but finds the second act slow.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Bringing The Fantasticks to Broadway after decades of Off Broadway success gives a wider audience a chance to encounter a celebrated musical, while the new casting offers a fresh perspective on its story of young love and family conflict. The production preserves the show’s whimsical character and familiar songs, and its first Broadway staging is a meaningful milestone.
The case against
A Broadway debut decades after a show’s original success may invite scrutiny over whether it still feels fresh, and the review’s criticism that the contrived second act drags suggests the production does not fully overcome that challenge. The gender recasting may offer a new perspective, but some viewers could feel that a familiar work’s lasting appeal rests on its established character and that changes do not resolve its underlying weaknesses.
Explained simply
The Fantasticks is a musical about two young people whose parents pretend to oppose their romance, hoping that the lovers will be drawn together. Its songs include “Try to Remember” and “Soon It’s Gonna Rain”, and its whimsical story has long been a fixture of American theatre.
The original production opened Off Broadway in 1960 and ran for 42 years, making it one of the best-known long-running musicals in New York. The Broadway production keeps the familiar story and music while casting the young couple as two boys and their feuding parents as mothers, bringing a new perspective to a show with a long history.