Entertainment news and discussion on TalkFuse.
The “garbage” 1967 movie so bad Roger Ebert walked out of it twice: “I was literally unable”
The article revisits Roger Ebert’s unusually strong reaction to *Jonathan Livingston Seagull*, a film he considered so poor that he left before it ended. It presents the walkout as notable because Ebert generally stayed through bad films in order to review them properly, making his response a measure of how profoundly the film failed for him.
Released in 1973 and adapted from Richard Bach’s bestselling novella, the film follows a seagull pursuing self-improvement and nonconformity. Ebert left after about 45 minutes, criticising its pretensions and its treatment of real birds; he later described it as a particularly hollow attempt at metaphysical storytelling. The article places it among the small number of films he publicly said he could not endure.
In short
- Ebert walked out of *Jonathan Livingston Seagull* after 45 minutes.
- He regarded its spiritual message as empty and pretentious.
- The walkout was rare in Ebert’s reviewing career.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Those who appreciate Jonathan Livingston Seagull argue that it represents a sincere attempt to translate spiritual philosophy into visual storytelling that continues to resonate with audiences decades later. They contend that Ebert's departure prevented him from fairly assessing the complete artistic vision, and that dismissing ambitious cinema that challenges mainstream conventions without experiencing the full work demonstrates limited critical openness.
The case against
Those who support Ebert's assessment argue that the film demonstrates fundamental failures in execution evident well before its midpoint, making his walkout a reasonable exercise of critical judgment. They maintain that cinema need not be endured in full if its artistic bankruptcy becomes apparent, and that Ebert's unusual reaction accurately reflects a film of genuine mediocrity.
Explained simply
Roger Ebert was an American film critic known for reviewing films for the Chicago Sun-Times and for usually watching them through, even when he disliked them. His response to a film could therefore attract attention when he chose to leave before it ended.
Jonathan Livingston Seagull was released in 1973 and adapted from Richard Bach’s bestselling novella. It follows a seagull seeking to improve himself and live outside the flock’s rules, and its story of personal growth and freedom was presented in a spiritual, reflective style.
Ebert objected to the film’s storytelling and its use of real birds. His reaction matters as an example of how far a film could fall short of his expectations, rather than as a measure of how all viewers or critics received it.