Business news and discussion on TalkFuse.
The Guardian view on the Grenfell Tower fire: Britain is letting companies pass the buck | Editorial
This Guardian editorial argues that Britain's system of corporate accountability failed the victims of the Grenfell Tower fire, in which 72 people, including 18 children, died in June 2017. Arconic, the company whose cladding the public inquiry found was the "primary cause" of the fire's rapid spread, paid more in Grenfell-related settlements to its insurers than out of its own pocket, while the multibillion-pound cost of making other buildings safe has fallen largely on the state; almost a decade on, nobody has faced criminal charges.
A new report from thinktank Common Wealth and financial investigations group FIND proposes two legal reforms for England and Wales: a "failure to prevent" law making firms responsible for guarding against foreseeable harm, and a "punitive damages" system, as used in the US, that would make companies pay according to their conduct rather than just compensating losses. Of Arconic's £86m in settlements, only £1.5m came from the company itself, with insurers covering the rest. The piece contrasts Britain's slow response, with police still investigating 57 individuals and 20 organisations and no charges expected before the tenth anniversary, with Hong Kong's Wang Fuk Court fire, where manslaughter charges were brought within seven months.
In short
- Grenfell cladding firm Arconic paid little of its own money in settlements
- Report urges new "failure to prevent" and punitive damages laws
- No criminal charges brought nearly a decade after the 2017 fire
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Britain's system has demonstrably failed to ensure corporate accountability for the Grenfell disaster. Arconic's cladding was found by the inquiry to be the primary cause of the fire's rapid spread that killed 72 people, yet the company itself paid only £1.5m of £86m in settlements, with insurers covering the remainder whilst taxpayers bear the massive cost of remediating other buildings. A decade later, despite clear findings of responsibility, no criminal charges have been brought. A 'failure to prevent' law would establish proper corporate responsibility for foreseeable harms, whilst punitive damages would ensure consequences commensurate with the wrongdoing's severity. Without such reforms, companies can effectively transfer accountability to their insurers and leave the public to pay.
The case against
The ongoing investigations reflect an appropriately thorough approach that ensures criminal justice rather than hasty charges. Criminal liability properly carries a high burden of proof and demands careful evidence gathering; delays reflect responsible due process, not systemic failure. A 'failure to prevent' law could impose excessive liability for matters beyond companies' reasonable foresight, whilst punitive damages risk producing arbitrary awards exceeding compensatory requirements. The public inquiry has established facts and responsibility; insurance-based settlements ensure victims receive funds. Regulatory strengthening and upgraded building standards may prevent future incidents more effectively than creating broad new legal frameworks that could have unintended consequences.
Explained simply
Grenfell Tower was a block of flats in west London where a fire in June 2017 killed 72 people, including 18 children. A public inquiry found that cladding made by Arconic was the primary cause of the fire spreading rapidly; the inquiry also examined decisions by companies and public bodies involved in the building’s refurbishment and safety.
The case has raised questions about how companies are held responsible when their products or decisions contribute to serious harm. The costs of making other buildings safe have fallen largely on the state, while criminal investigations into the fire have not yet led to charges.
A report by Common Wealth and FIND proposes changes to the law in England and Wales, including making firms responsible for preventing foreseeable harm and allowing courts to impose higher payments based on a company’s conduct. Such proposals concern how the law might address corporate responsibility and help pay for the consequences of harm.
Business Companies Government Politics UK World