Culture news and discussion on TalkFuse.
The Importance of Being Earnest review – gloriously madcap opera achieves new heights of delirium
Garsington Opera in Stokenchurch has staged a new production of Gerald Barry's operatic adaptation of Oscar Wilde's The Importance of Being Earnest, directed by Jack Furness. Barry's version already reworks Wilde's "trivial comedy for serious people" into what he calls "an opera of delirium", setting the play's famous punchlines to a staccato hybrid of speech and singing, and Furness's hyperactive staging pushes the zaniness still further.
The production piles on surreal stage business, including a grand piano on stilts, a herd of miniature cows, a kangaroo that meets a grisly end, a chaise longue-cum-slide, and a muddy dirt floor with a working hose, though the reviewer felt these efforts to shock slowed the pace and soured the comedy. Bass-baritone Henry Waddington drew the loudest laughs as a bearded, gun-toting Lady Bracknell, while the ensemble cast — including Jennifer France as Cecily, Zahid Siddiqui as Jack and Seán Boylan as Algernon — was praised for its diction and comic timing, with Kevin Whately in the speaking role of Dr Chasuble. Douglas Boyd conducted a subset of the Philharmonia Orchestra, and the critic concluded that the opera has achieved lasting life beyond its premiere.
In short
- Garsington Opera revives Gerald Barry's madcap operatic take on Wilde's comedy.
- Jack Furness's surreal staging features stilts, cows and a doomed kangaroo.
- Henry Waddington's bearded Lady Bracknell earned the biggest laughs.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The adaptation of Wilde into Barry's 'opera of delirium' demands surrealist staging that matches its inherent absurdism. Furness's hyperactive direction—with stilted pianos, miniature cows, and other fantastical elements—appropriately complements Barry's staccato speech-singing hybrid, whilst the ensemble's praised diction and comic timing show that spectacle and performance can coexist. Contemporary opera audiences expect visual innovation and imagination alongside the music, making such staging both artistically justified and theatrically appropriate for the medium.
The case against
Comedy fundamentally depends on clarity, pace, and focus; excessive stage business—however creative—distracts from the verbal wit and character dynamics that make Wilde's play endure. The elaborate spectacle slows the comedic momentum and pulls attention from punchlines to set pieces, ultimately souring the humour rather than enhancing it. The text and performances should be trusted to carry the comedy, and restraint often proves more effective than an ever-escalating attempt to visually top every moment.
Explained simply
Oscar Wilde's The Importance of Being Earnest is a celebrated comedy from the 1890s, famous for its witty dialogue and its plot full of mistaken identities and romantic confusion. Composer Gerald Barry has transformed it into an opera, setting Wilde's lines to music combined with spoken words.
Garsington Opera in Stokenchurch has staged this operatic adaptation, directed by Jack Furness. The production combines elaborate and surreal stage designs with the music to heighten the comedy and absurdity of the original work.
Barry's musical version shows a modern approach to reimagining classical works for the stage. It demonstrates how well-known plays and stories can be transformed through different art forms and contemporary theatrical methods.