World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
The Mets have a tortured history of adding Cy Young winners. Could Tarik Skubal end the misery?
The Mets have a strong tradition of producing Cy Young winners, but their record with award-winning pitchers acquired from other teams has been mixed. Tarik Skubal, who met Mets officials this week while pursuing a potentially record-setting pitching contract, could become the latest former winner to join them.
Skubal won consecutive Cy Young awards with the Detroit Tigers and is described as a top arm, unlike many past Mets acquisitions who were nearing the end of their careers. The article frames a possible move as part of the club’s unusual history of signing pitchers who had already won the award, though it gives no contract terms or outcome.
In short
- Skubal met with Mets officials this week.
- He has won two consecutive Cy Young awards.
- A move would add to the Mets’ mixed history with former winners.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Signing Tarik Skubal could give the Mets an established, elite starter in his prime, a rare chance to strengthen the rotation with a proven award winner rather than a veteran nearing the end of his career. If the club can make the commitment fit its plans, the move could address a major competitive need and turn its history of acquiring Cy Young winners in a more promising direction.
The case against
A record-setting contract for a pitcher carries substantial financial and performance risk, even when he has been exceptional; injuries or decline could leave the club with less flexibility to build a balanced roster. The Mets’ mixed history with acquired Cy Young winners also cautions that past awards alone do not ensure that a high-cost signing will deliver lasting value.
Explained simply
The Cy Young Award is given each year to the best pitcher in each of Major League Baseball’s two leagues. The Mets are a New York team in the National League; the Detroit Tigers play in the American League.
Tarik Skubal won the award in consecutive seasons with Detroit. The Mets have signed several pitchers who had already won a Cy Young, with mixed results, and some arrived late in their careers. Skubal is younger and regarded as a leading pitcher, making him a different kind of potential addition.
A move could matter because elite starting pitchers can shape a team’s performance, while a record-setting contract would be a major commitment. The Mets’ past signings provide context, but they do not determine how a new one would turn out.