Entertainment news and discussion on TalkFuse.
The Most Criminally Underrated Album Released Every Year From 1970 to 1974
An American Songwriter feature picks out one overlooked album from each year of 1970 to 1974, arguing that these releases deserved far greater commercial success and recognition at the time. The writer highlights records spanning folk, prog-folk, progressive rock and psych-rock, noting how several have since gained cult followings despite performing poorly on the charts on release.
The selections are Vashti Bunyan's "Just Another Diamond Day" (1970), whose commercial failure led her to quit music for years before it was rediscovered; Comus's dark prog-folk record "First Utterance" (1971); Gentle Giant's "Octopus" (1972), which only reached No. 170 on the Billboard 200; Ofege's "Try And Love" (1973), made by Nigerian teenagers and now seen as a landmark of Nigerian psych-rock; and Kansas's self-titled 1974 debut, overshadowed by their later hit "Leftoverture" and never reaching the Top 100.
In short
- Five underrated albums picked, one per year, 1970–1974.
- Includes Vashti Bunyan, Comus, Gentle Giant, Ofege and Kansas.
- Most flopped commercially but later gained cult status.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
These albums demonstrate genuine artistic innovation and creative merit that transcended the commercial expectations of their era. The fact that many have become cult classics and been re-evaluated by critics shows that their original commercial failure resulted from market limitations, distribution barriers, or inadequate promotion rather than from any actual lack of quality. Calling them underrated properly acknowledges that the true artistic worth of these recordings was obscured by circumstances beyond their creative substance, and subsequent critical appreciation vindicates this assessment.
The case against
Commercial performance in one's own era is a reasonable and relevant metric for evaluating whether an album was genuinely underrated at the time. Using contemporary market success to judge these albums in the 1970s is more honest than retroactively applying modern critical fashions or cult appreciation to historical events. An album that failed to sell at the time may later gain admirers, but this does not necessarily mean it was underrated then; it may simply mean tastes evolved, or particular audiences discovered it later, and retrospective cult status should not be confused with historical undervaluation.
Explained simply
Album sales and chart positions offer one measure of a record’s success, but some albums find their audience years later. Reissues, music writing and word of mouth can help overlooked records gain devoted listeners long after their release.
The albums in this story come from different musical scenes: Vashti Bunyan’s British folk, Comus’s prog-folk, Gentle Giant’s progressive rock, Nigeria’s Ofege and the American band Kansas. Their varied styles reflect a period when rock and folk musicians were experimenting with unusual arrangements and sounds.
The artists’ later fortunes also differed. Bunyan stepped away from music after her album failed commercially, while some of the other records became cult favourites; Kansas later found wider success with a subsequent album. This background helps explain why a record’s reputation can change over time.