Entertainment news and discussion on TalkFuse.
The Most Successful Horror Movie of the Century Is Officially Being Taken to Court
Executive producer Leonora Ann Darby has filed a breach of contract lawsuit against James Harris and Mark Lane, accusing the pair of denying her a fair share of the profits from Obsession, the record-breaking horror hit made through their company Tea Shop Productions. The 135-page complaint, lodged on 28 August in Los Angeles Superior Court, alleges a "seven-year pattern of unequal treatment and broken compensation promises" and claims Darby was demeaned and sidelined despite being instrumental to the film's success.
Darby says she joined Tea Shop in 2019 on the understanding she would be an equal producer, entitled to a third of net profits on films she led, but claims she was instead treated as a subordinate. Obsession, directed by breakout YouTuber Curry Barker, turned a budget of under $1 million into a global gross of roughly $510 million, making it the most successful original horror film of the century, yet Darby says she received only an initial payment plus a later $300,000 sum, far short of her promised cut.
In short
- Producer Leonora Ann Darby sues Tea Shop Productions over Obsession profits.
- Claims broken promise of one-third net profit share since 2019.
- Obsession grossed about $510 million from a sub-$1m budget.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Darby’s strongest case is that an equal-producer role and a third share of net profits were part of her agreement, and that her work materially contributed to a film’s exceptional success. If the promised terms were clear and she was paid far less than her agreed share, seeking a legal remedy would be a reasonable way to enforce the contract and secure fair compensation.
The case against
Harris and Lane could argue that producer status and compensation depend on the precise contracts, accounting and agreed definition of net profits, rather than on the film’s success alone. They may dispute that Darby was promised an equal share or contend that her payments matched the terms and contributions agreed; those questions require evidence and have not been resolved by the filing of a complaint.
Explained simply
Obsession was made by Tea Shop Productions, a company run by producers James Harris and Mark Lane. Its director, Curry Barker, was previously known for making videos on YouTube. The film was produced on a budget of under $1 million and went on to earn about $510 million worldwide.
Leonora Ann Darby says she joined Tea Shop in 2019 expecting to be an equal producer and to receive a third of the net profits from films she led. She says she helped make Obsession a success but was paid only an initial amount and a later $300,000. The dispute matters because it concerns how producers’ roles and shares of a film’s profits were agreed and paid.