Video games news, releases, esports and culture — all the biggest gaming stories in one place.
The Odyssey’s glowing reviews from audiences and critics are silencing its biggest haters
Christopher Nolan's latest adaptation of Homer's epic opened in cinemas with widespread critical and audience approval, recording 97% positive audience ratings and 96% critical scores on Rotten Tomatoes. The film's release followed months of online debate initiated by various commentators who objected to casting and creative decisions before the film's debut, including concerns about Matt Damon's casting as Odysseus, period-accurate costume choices, and the racial composition of the ensemble cast.
The film generated $17.6 million in preview screenings, exceeding any other 2025 release in that category, suggesting audience enthusiasm has translated into commercial performance. Director Nolan had largely dismissed the pre-release criticisms as inevitable preliminary discourse, noting that those participating in such discussions lacked actual knowledge of the finished film.
In short
- Nolan's adaptation received strong critical (96%) and audience (97%) approval on Rotten Tomatoes
- Pre-release controversy centered on casting diversity and period authenticity concerns
- Record preview box office ($17.6M) indicates commercial success despite online backlash
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The extraordinary critical and audience approval—97% and 96% on Rotten Tomatoes respectively—demonstrates that the filmmakers' creative choices, from casting to costume design, were sound and justified. Director Nolan was correct that online criticism prior to a film's release typically stems from incomplete information, and the film's universal acclaim proves his creative team's judgment vindicated. When a film with these particular casting and representation decisions achieves near-universal praise, it indicates that those voicing preliminary concerns were reacting to hypothetical worries rather than the actual finished work.
The case against
Whilst the film's critical success is noteworthy, it does not invalidate legitimate pre-release concerns about casting decisions and representation in the ensemble cast. Questions about who is chosen for major roles and how diverse an ensemble is constitute important cultural conversations that exist independently of whether a finished film is well-made. The fact that audiences and critics appreciate the final product does not render the preliminary concerns baseless; rather, it means the filmmakers achieved quality whilst making specific creative choices that were worth discussing openly before release.
Explained simply
Christopher Nolan is directing a film adaptation of Homer's ancient epic poem The Odyssey, which tells of a warrior's long and perilous journey home after war. Nolan is known for his high-budget, visually ambitious blockbuster films.
The film attracted significant online discussion and criticism before its cinema release. Various commentators objected to the casting of Matt Damon in the lead role, the choice to use period-accurate costumes and design, and the racial composition of the cast.
Nolan had dismissed these pre-release concerns, arguing that those without knowledge of the finished film could not fairly judge it. The film has since been released and received positive ratings from critics and audiences.