New releases, music videos and album news — indie, rap, rock and pop. Always covering Ren, Chris Webby, Sam Tompkins, bbno$, CHINCHILLA, Muse, Yungblud and more.
The “ridiculous” 2012 role Greta Gerwig was talked into playing: “It feels kind of disgusting”
Greta Gerwig initially hesitated to star in *Frances Ha*, the 2012 film she co-wrote with director Noah Baumbach, because she felt the arrangement seemed overly self-indulgent. Baumbach reportedly dismissed her concerns as “ridiculous”, and Gerwig ultimately took the title role in a film that became a significant early milestone in her rise as a filmmaker and actor.
Gerwig compared writing and starring in the same project to “baking a cake and eating it yourself”, saying it felt “kind of disgusting” and likening the undertaking to Orson Welles. *Frances Ha*, shot in black and white on a small budget, follows an aspiring dancer navigating friendship and adulthood in New York; Gerwig’s performance helped establish her as a major independent-film talent.
In short
- Gerwig was reluctant to star in co-written film *Frances Ha*.
- Baumbach persuaded her to play the lead.
- The role became a key career breakthrough.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Gerwig's concern about self-indulgence reflects genuine artistic risk. When one person writes and stars in a project, there is danger of unjustified expansion of their role, self-flattering dialogue, and compromised judgment clouded by personal investment. Separating creative roles exists partly to maintain objectivity and external accountability in artistic decisions, protecting against the natural temptation towards excess that concentrating power creates.
The case against
Writer-actors have produced excellent work throughout cinema's history, from Chaplin to Welles, demonstrating that unified vision can be artistically productive rather than self-serving. Filmmaking is inherently collaborative—directors, cinematographers, editors, and fellow performers provide ongoing external perspective and constraint. The critical success of Frances Ha itself proves that Gerwig's concerns were misplaced, vindicating that her dual role enhanced the film and showing such arrangements need not be inherently self-indulgent.
Explained simply
Frances Ha is a 2012 independent film about Frances, an aspiring dancer in New York trying to find her footing in work, friendship and adult life. It was made in black and white on a small budget and directed by Noah Baumbach.
Greta Gerwig co-wrote the film with Baumbach and played Frances. She later became known as both an actor and a filmmaker, and the film was an early milestone in her career.
Gerwig said she was uneasy about writing and starring in the same film, comparing it to making a cake and eating it herself. Baumbach urged her to take the role, and her performance helped bring wider attention to her work.