Entertainment news and discussion on TalkFuse.
‘The Rings of Power’s Most Shocking Proposal Just Set Up Númenor’s Ultimate Fate
Míriel accepts Ar-Pharazôn’s proposal of marriage in the hope of uniting Númenor’s rival factions and preventing civil war. The decision matters because Tolkien’s history points towards Pharazôn’s rise, his alliance with Sauron and the eventual destruction of the island kingdom.
In the series, the King’s Men are fighting the Faithful, who worship Eru Ilúvatar and the Valar; Míriel hopes the marriage will protect the Faithful and curb the King’s Men’s influence. Pharazôn is expected to take Sauron prisoner, but Sauron’s influence leads Númenor towards Melkor worship and, in Tolkien’s account, a disastrous attempt to reach Valinor that ends with a Great Wave destroying the realm. Elendil appears to fear the marriage will bring that fate closer.
In short
- Míriel agrees to marry Pharazôn to try to prevent civil war.
- The union is expected to heighten tensions between Númenor’s factions.
- Tolkien’s history foreshadows Sauron’s influence and Númenor’s destruction.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Míriel’s acceptance can be defended as a pragmatic attempt to prevent civil war and preserve the Faithful’s place in Númenor. By joining the rival factions at the centre of power, she may be able to restrain the King’s Men and protect people who would otherwise face greater persecution.
The case against
The marriage could strengthen Pharazôn’s claim to rule and give the King’s Men greater influence, while leaving Míriel with less ability to resist their aims. Given the known trajectory of Númenor’s history, Elendil’s fear is that a pact meant to secure peace will instead help bring the kingdom closer to Sauron’s influence and its eventual destruction.
Explained simply
Númenor is an island kingdom in Tolkien’s history, divided between the King’s Men and the Faithful. The King’s Men favour Númenor’s independence from the Elves and the Valar, while the Faithful worship Eru Ilúvatar and the Valar. Míriel is the queen; Ar-Pharazôn is a powerful leader among the King’s Men.
The marriage is intended to bring the rival factions together and reduce the risk of civil war. Tolkien’s account says Pharazôn later takes Sauron to Númenor, where Sauron gains influence over the kingdom. The story ultimately links that influence to Númenor’s downfall: its rulers turn towards Melkor and attempt to reach Valinor, before a Great Wave destroys the island.