Entertainment news and discussion on TalkFuse.
The single worst movie of 1982, according to Roger Ebert: “Absolutely awful”
Roger Ebert named *Six Weeks*, Tony Bill’s 1982 drama, the year’s worst film, calling it “absolutely awful”. His verdict stood out in a year that also produced celebrated films such as *E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial*, *Blade Runner* and *The Thing*, and the disagreement with fellow critic Gene Siskel showed how sharply the film divided opinion.
The story follows 12-year-old Nicole, who has leukaemia, as her mother helps her fulfil her wishes; Nicole befriends politician Patrick Dalton, played by Dudley Moore, and hopes he will become part of her family. Siskel liked the film, while Ebert objected to its sentimentality and shifting focus between Nicole’s illness and a romance involving her mother. Mary Tyler Moore was nominated for a Razzie, while Dudley Moore and Katherine Healy received Golden Globe nominations.
In short
- Roger Ebert called *Six Weeks* the worst film of 1982.
- Gene Siskel liked the drama, but Ebert strongly disagreed.
- The film mixed a child’s illness with a romance plot.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
A sympathetic case for Six Weeks is that its sentimental approach gives emotional weight to Nicole’s limited time and her wish for a loving family. Its performances and appeal to compassion may explain why Siskel and awards voters responded warmly, even if the film takes dramatic liberties.
The case against
A critical case is that the film’s sentimentality can feel manipulative, using Nicole’s illness to steer the audience towards emotion rather than earning it through credible development. The shift between her story and her mother’s romance may also weaken the focus and make the drama feel incoherent.
Explained simply
Six Weeks is a 1982 drama directed by Tony Bill. It follows Nicole, a 12-year-old with leukaemia, and her mother as they try to make the most of Nicole’s time; Nicole also grows close to politician Patrick Dalton, played by Dudley Moore.
Film critics Roger Ebert and Gene Siskel disagreed about the film: Ebert objected to its emotional tone and changing focus, while Siskel liked it. Their differing views reflect how a film’s treatment of illness, family and romance can divide audiences and critics.