Culture news and discussion on TalkFuse.
The wearable future is stuck in weird, experimental, existential limbo
Google is grappling with how to shape the next generation of wearable technology, according to a discussion between The Verge's Victoria Song and Google executives ahead of its Made by Google event. While the industry broadly agrees on a shared vision — AI coaches, preventive "check engine" health alerts, and personalised recommendations — companies, including Google, appear uncertain how to actually deliver it, with each element facing significant practical hurdles.
Google's health and home VP, Rishi Chandra, noted that wearables have historically catered to hardcore health enthusiasts even though wearable penetration stands at only around 30%, leaving 70% of people untapped. Current AI coaches are described as overly chatty and fixated on minor details, health alerts risk causing anxiety and regulatory complications, and personalised health tools demand extensive private data while inheriting AI's existing flaws. Google's stated response, first outlined a year ago by Chandra and wearables director Sandeep Waraich, is to move away from a single flagship device towards a broader ecosystem of diverse wearables, a shift already reflected in the industry's growing pivot towards AI glasses and other screenless devices.
In short
- Wearable tech's AI-driven future remains unclear despite shared industry ambitions
- Google eyes a multi-device ecosystem rather than one smartwatch
- Only 30% of people currently use wearables, Google says
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The wearable industry should serve broader populations by developing diverse, ecosystem-oriented products even with acknowledged limitations, rather than serving only devoted enthusiasts indefinitely. Technology improves through real-world deployment and feedback; refusing to offer imperfect solutions to the 70% untapped market deprives people of useful tools and eliminates the learning needed for improvement. A varied ecosystem allows different products for different risk tolerances. Companies have a responsibility to iterate in the market, with transparent limitations, rather than withholding potentially beneficial technology.
The case against
Companies should prioritise resolving foundational issues before expanding wearables to mass audiences, particularly around privacy safeguards, health alert validation, and regulatory clarity. Deploying imperfect health technology widely risks normalising poor data practices, creating unnecessary anxiety through unreliable alerts, and breeding distrust in health innovation. The sector's acknowledgement that AI systems inherit societal flaws suggests premature expansion would compound these problems across millions of users. Better to perfect technology for current users than to scale problems across the untapped majority.
Explained simply
Wearables are devices such as smartwatches and fitness bands that collect information about their users, often including activity, sleep and heart rate. Many have been designed for people who already closely track their health, while companies are exploring ways to make them useful to a wider audience.
Google executives Rishi Chandra and Sandeep Waraich have described a move towards a range of connected devices rather than relying on one main product. The wider industry is also looking at screenless devices, including AI glasses, as it considers how people might use technology throughout the day.
The longer-term idea is for devices to offer coaching, spot possible health concerns and tailor advice to each person. Those features raise questions about whether alerts are reliable and helpful, how much personal data they need, and how to avoid overwhelming or worrying users.
Art Culture Entertainment Gadgets Music Offbeat Research Science Technology Weird & Viral