News, events and chat from Sheffield and South Yorkshire.
The ‘working-class lad from Sheffield’ who became a Lord despite father’s ‘wildest dreams’
Lord Shaffaq Mohammed, who describes himself as a "working-class lad from Sheffield," has reflected on his first 18 months as a member of the House of Lords, telling of the pride his family would never have imagined. Born in Kashmir, he moved to Tinsley in Sheffield aged four in 1977, rose through local politics to lead the city's Liberal Democrats in 2011, and was nominated for a life peerage in December 2024 before taking his seat as Lord Mohammed of Tinsley in February. His story matters as part of a wider debate about how representative the Lords is, coming soon after the abolition of hereditary peers.
He recalled an emotional moment hearing Winston Churchill's grandson Nicolas Soames speak, reflecting that while his own grandfather tended camels in Kashmir, their votes now count equally, and that his late father, a steelworker who died in 1995, could never have dreamed of him reaching Sheffield Council, let alone the Lords. Now 54, he says he is sometimes called "young man" given the chamber's average age of over 70, and argues the Lords still fails to reflect ordinary society, contrasting his 2011 Skoda with peers arriving in Rolls-Royces. Despite holding a life peerage himself, he says he would vote to abolish life peers too, calling for more voices from backgrounds such as hospital cleaners and car mechanics.
In short
- Lord Shaffaq Mohammed reflects on first 18 months in House of Lords
- Working-class Sheffield upbringing shaped his outsider perspective on peerage
- He backs abolishing life peers, wants Lords to better reflect society
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Mohammed’s appointment shows how the Lords can bring people with different regional, class and migrant backgrounds into national debate, and his experience may help expose gaps in representation. Supporters of life peerages can argue that appointments allow expertise and public service beyond electoral politics to be recognised, while reforms could broaden the range of voices in the chamber.
The case against
The Lords’ continued reliance on appointed members can be seen as an undemocratic way to exercise legislative influence, even when appointees have varied backgrounds and public-service records. Critics may argue that one person’s success does not make the chamber representative, and that replacing hereditary peers with life peers leaves the deeper questions of selection, accountability and social access unresolved.
Explained simply
The House of Lords is the UK Parliament’s second chamber, where members scrutinise proposed laws and government decisions. Most members are appointed for life as life peers; until recently, some also inherited their seats, but hereditary membership has now been abolished.
Shaffaq Mohammed was born in Kashmir and moved to Sheffield as a child. He entered local politics and led the city’s Liberal Democrats before becoming a life peer, taking the title Lord Mohammed of Tinsley.
His experience feeds into questions about who gets a voice in Parliament and whether the Lords reflects the wider population. The debate includes whether appointed members should remain and how people from a broader range of jobs and backgrounds could be represented.