Politics news and discussion on TalkFuse.
There’s probably a cult hiding in plain sight on your high street. At last, Britain is confronting the problem | Rachael Reign
MPs have brought the harm caused by high-control groups into mainstream political debate, prompting calls for stronger protections and a review of whether current laws are adequate. The author, a specialist who supports survivors, welcomes the attention but argues that recognition must lead to practical action.
The debate, led by Labour MP Sam Carling, named the Universal Church of the Kingdom of God and other groups; the church is a registered charity with branches across Britain and has been investigated by the BBC’s Panorama and national newspapers. The article also points to updated Crown Prosecution Service guidance on spiritual abuse, plans for an all-party parliamentary group and a call for national evidence. It says the Home Office has rejected extending the coercive-control offence beyond personally connected relationships, leaving some patterns of sustained psychological coercion difficult to address.
In short
- MPs debated harm linked to high-control religious groups.
- Survivors want stronger protections and a review of the law.
- The Home Office has opposed widening the coercive-control offence.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Supporters of stronger protections argue that high-control groups can use sustained psychological pressure and spiritual abuse to cause serious harm, while people outside personally connected relationships may fall beyond existing coercive-control law. Parliamentary scrutiny, better evidence gathering and a review of legal gaps could help survivors seek redress and make responses more consistent. These steps need not presume that any particular group is guilty; they can focus on conduct and demonstrable harm.
The case against
Those cautious about expanding protections can argue that broad laws aimed at “high-control groups” risk making contested beliefs or unconventional religious practice the focus of state scrutiny. Existing criminal offences and updated prosecution guidance may address specific abusive conduct, while further evidence is needed to show where the law fails and what remedy would work. A measured approach can protect religious freedom and avoid creating vague powers that are difficult to apply fairly.