Business news and discussion on TalkFuse.
This nanny state Government is writing off a generation of young people before they’ve even started
The article argues that government rules and welfare policy risk making it harder for young people to find work, at a time when almost a million are not in employment, education or training. It backs former health secretary Alan Milburn’s proposed overhaul, which aims to shift support towards jobs and training and away from long-term reliance on benefits.
A review by NHS adviser Peter Fonagy found that lack of opportunity is a major factor and that one in four 16 to 24-year-olds struggle with their mental health. Milburn’s report is expected to propose redirecting £22 billion spent annually on benefits for under-25s, including a legally enforceable jobs or training guarantee and changes to health-related payments. The article says job schemes and lower employer National Insurance contributions for younger workers would require upfront spending, with savings expected over time.
In short
- The article argues policy is making youth employment harder.
- Alan Milburn proposes redirecting £22 billion towards work support.
- A jobs or training guarantee is among the expected reforms.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
With almost a million young people outside work, education or training, and mental health difficulties affecting many more, the current approach may be failing to offer a credible route into adult life. Support tied to a guaranteed job or training place could restore opportunity and confidence, while redirecting some benefit spending towards early help may reduce long-term dependency and costs.
The case against
Benefits and health-related payments can provide essential security for young people facing illness, disability or barriers that a job scheme cannot quickly resolve. Changing eligibility or shifting funds before suitable jobs, training and support are available could deepen hardship and worsen mental health; promised future savings are uncertain, while the upfront costs and risks fall on young people now.
Explained simply
Across the UK, young people aged 16 to 24 may be in work, education or training, or outside all three. People in the last group are often called NEET; the number has approached one million, while mental health difficulties affect many young people.
Alan Milburn, a former health secretary, has been asked to examine how to improve young people’s prospects. His review is expected to consider moving support towards jobs and training, including a guarantee of a job or training place, and changes to health-related benefits.
The debate is about how best to help young people into work while supporting those who are unwell or unable to work. The proposals also raise questions about how much to spend now on employment schemes and employer incentives, and whether that could reduce benefit costs over time.
Business Europe Government Markets Politics World