Politics news and discussion on TalkFuse.
This Supreme Court “Deserves Our Celebration, Not Our Condemnation”
William Baude argues that the US Supreme Court has shown independence by ruling against important Trump administration policies, despite six justices having been appointed by Republican presidents. He says this record merits recognition and warns that changing the Court to reverse particular rulings risks turning it into a political weapon.
Baude accepts that bipartisan reform may be appropriate, but says partisan changes driven by dissatisfaction with specific decisions could invite retaliation from the other side. He also doubts that ethics rules on gifts, travel or outside income would significantly affect rulings, and suggests reform may work chiefly as a way to reassure the public and shift attention to other issues.
In short
- Baude says the Court has constrained Trump administration policies.
- He warns partisan reform could make the Court a political weapon.
- Ethics rules are unlikely to change the justices’ rulings.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The Court’s willingness to rule against major policies of an administration whose party appointed most of its justices is evidence that it can act independently of partisan expectations. Celebrating that record may help preserve public trust, while changing the Court in response to particular rulings could make it seem—and function—more like a political instrument. Reforms agreed across party lines may be legitimate, but ethics rules should not be assumed to change judicial outcomes if the evidence for that effect is weak.
The case against
A record of rulings against one administration does not by itself establish that the Court is broadly independent or that its decisions are fair; critics may judge it by its reasoning, consistency and accountability as well. Public confidence can also be weakened when justices face limited ethics constraints, even if tighter rules do not directly alter their votes. Carefully designed structural or ethics reforms could therefore protect the Court’s legitimacy, and the risk of political retaliation is a reason to craft reforms cautiously rather than avoid them.
Explained simply
The US Supreme Court is the country’s highest court. It decides how the Constitution and federal laws apply, and its rulings can limit actions by the president and Congress.
The Court has nine justices, nominated by the president and confirmed by the Senate, usually for life. Its current members were appointed by presidents from both parties, though six were appointed by Republican presidents.
Debates about reform often concern the Court’s size, ethics rules or how justices are appointed. Changes made chiefly to alter particular decisions could prompt retaliation by a later government, raising questions about the Court’s independence and public trust.