Thomas Tuchel is facing heavy criticism after England's 1-2 World Cup semi-final defeat to Argentina, with pundits including Wayne Rooney arguing that his substitutions and tactical changes cost the Three Lions the match. Columnist Ian Ladyman writes that Tuchel's decisions left England "out of ideas" and represented a return to the cautious, fear-driven approach for which Gareth Southgate was previously criticised, an accusation made more pointed given Tuchel had earlier claimed England played with "fear" under Southgate. Despite the backlash, the FA is reported to retain full confidence in the German coach, who is expected to stay in post.

England led before being pegged back, with several former players and commentators dissecting the tactical breakdown and a "damning" second-half statistic in the aftermath. The defeat was further overshadowed by ugly scenes, including Jude Bellingham being filmed slapping an Argentinian opponent amid celebrations, and Argentina players holding up a banner referencing the Falkland Islands after the final whistle. Tuchel has defended his gameplan, insisting it is "easy" for critics to call it wrong in hindsight, while captain Harry Kane admitted uncertainty over whether this was his last World Cup appearance.