Entertainment news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Time to end music’s greatest injustice
Scott Cohen, co-founder of The Orchard and former Warner Music Group chief innovation officer, has written an opinion piece arguing that the music industry's biggest deals systematically exclude the artists whose catalogues and rights created the underlying value. He draws on his own experience selling The Orchard to Sony Music in 2015, when the artists whose music built the company's worth received nothing from the sale, to argue that royalty payments alone do not reflect an artist's true contribution to a company's value.
Cohen points to more than $12 billion in acquisitions and mergers of distribution platforms, royalty administrators and music catalogues announced in the first half of 2026, including Virgin Music's purchase of Downtown, the Primary Wave/Kobalt deal, the BMG-Concord merger, Warner Music's acquisition of Revelator, and Sony Music Publishing's purchase of Recognition's (formerly Hipgnosis) rights portfolio. He stresses he isn't accusing anyone of wrongdoing, but calls for a mechanism, inspired by Web3 principles, that would let artists and rightsholders financially participate when companies are sold for value built substantially on their music and data.
In short
- Music exec says artists get nothing when catalogue-built firms are sold
- Cites $12bn+ in 2026 music industry M&A deals
- Calls for mechanism letting creators share in company sale value
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Artists' creative work is the foundational asset generating these companies' multibillion-pound valuations. When platforms like The Orchard succeed, it is the accumulated catalogue and data from creators that attract buyers willing to pay premiums. Royalties compensate for ongoing use, but not for the equity value created by artists' contributions. A participation mechanism would reflect artists' true role in building company value and would align incentives so that those whose work generated wealth share fairly in that wealth.
The case against
Companies create genuine value through infrastructure, technology, investment, and market development that artists benefit from but do not themselves provide. Artists entered into royalty agreements with known terms; retroactively demanding equity stakes would violate established contracts and discourage future investment in distribution platforms that serve the music industry. The acquisition premium reflects not just catalogues but the platform's operational value, relationships, and market position. Artists who wish equity stakes can negotiate for them, but cannot fairly demand them after the fact.
Explained simply
The music industry regularly generates enormous value when companies dealing with songs, artists' rights and music distribution change hands, but the artists whose work created much of that value typically receive nothing from the sale. They earn royalties from the music being used, but not from the financial transaction itself when a company is sold for millions or billions.
Scott Cohen, a music executive who co-founded The Orchard, a music distribution platform, is arguing this is unjust. When Sony Music bought The Orchard in 2015, the artists whose music had made the company valuable received nothing from the sale.
The industry has recently seen a major wave of such deals—over $12 billion worth of acquisitions announced in the first half of 2026 alone, involving distribution platforms, rights managers and music catalogues. Cohen is proposing a system that would allow artists and other rightsholders to share in the financial value when companies built substantially on their music and data are sold.