World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Top DHS lawyer turns tables on 128 ex-judges after Bar declines ‘Worst of Worst’ complaint
The US Department of Homeland Security's General Counsel, James Percival, has told the Florida Bar to scrutinise the 128 former judges who filed an ethics complaint against him, after the Bar declined to investigate his conduct. The dispute centres on Percival's "Worst of the Worst Judges" series, which criticised sitting judges over rulings on immigration and use-of-force policy, and which the former judges argued breached rules on public attacks against the judiciary. The row matters because it reflects a wider clash between the Trump administration and the judiciary over the limits of criticising judges' rulings, and raises questions about whether professional bodies can be used as tools in political disputes.
The Florida Bar said it does not investigate sitting officers appointed under the US Constitution while they remain in office, a stance Percival said the complainants should have anticipated. He accused the Bar members among the 128 signatories, led by former Florida Supreme Court Chief Justice Peggy Quince, of pursuing a frivolous complaint for political ends, coining the term "Bar-fare" and likening it to the 2020 episode involving 51 former intelligence officials and Hunter Biden's laptop. The judges' 24-page complaint, filed by groups including the Democracy Defenders Fund, had focused on four judges featured in Percival's posts over cases involving Temporary Protected Status, Kilmar Ábrego García and DHS use-of-force rules.
In short
- DHS lawyer Percival wants Florida Bar to probe ex-judges after complaint against him fails
- Bar won't investigate sitting constitutional officers, prompting Percival's "Bar-fare" claim
- Underlying row is over his "Worst of the Worst Judges" criticism series
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Percival’s supporters could argue that publicly criticising judges’ rulings is a legitimate form of political speech, particularly when government officials believe those rulings obstruct lawful policy. They may also say the Bar’s decision not to investigate reflects a procedural limit, and that complaints filed by politically active former judges risk turning professional discipline into a partisan weapon.
The case against
The former judges’ supporters could argue that senior government lawyers have a special responsibility to criticise judicial decisions without targeting judges in ways that may undermine confidence in impartial courts. They may see the complaint as a good-faith effort to uphold professional standards, and Percival’s counter-complaint as an attempt to deter scrutiny of official conduct.
Explained simply
James Percival is the US Department of Homeland Security’s general counsel, its senior legal adviser. He published a series criticising judges who ruled on immigration and the use of force by federal officers. More than 100 former judges argued that his comments may have breached professional rules against publicly attacking judges over their decisions.
The dispute involves the Florida Bar, which regulates lawyers in the state, and Peggy Quince, a former chief justice of Florida who led the complaint against Percival. The Bar said it does not investigate constitutional officers while they remain in office; Percival then called for scrutiny of the former judges who complained about him.
The row reflects broader tensions between the Trump administration and the courts over criticism of judicial decisions. It also raises questions about how legal regulators handle complaints when professional rules become part of a political dispute.
Americas Gadgets Technology World