Technology news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Truck driver fired for ‘unsafe’ use of smartglasses in first reported sacking over device in Australia
A Victorian truck driver was dismissed after using smartglasses to photograph a vehicle at an LPG terminal, where electrical equipment was considered a potential explosion risk. The federal circuit court upheld the seriousness of the incident, making this the first reported Australian case of a worker being sacked over smartglasses.
Ricardo Martins Silva had worked for Toll Transport for eight months as an LPG tanker driver when he took the photographs on 17 June 2025. He argued his dismissal followed workplace safety and employment complaints, and said unresolved trauma from an earlier truck fire had affected his judgement. Justice Karl Blake found he was dismissed because of the smartglasses incident, which Silva acknowledged he knew was wrong; his employment ended on 18 July.
In short
- Toll dismissed a driver for taking photos with smartglasses at an LPG terminal.
- The court found the incident was objectively very serious.
- The driver had also raised concerns about safety and working conditions.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The employer’s strongest case is that taking photographs with smartglasses in an LPG terminal created a serious safety risk around equipment that could potentially ignite an explosion. In a high-risk workplace, enforcing clear rules consistently may be necessary to protect workers and the public, and the court found the incident was the reason for dismissal.
The case against
Silva’s strongest case is that dismissal may have been unduly harsh if his workplace safety and employment complaints, or the effects of trauma from an earlier truck fire, influenced how the employer treated him. Even where a safety breach is serious, an employer could consider its context, the worker’s record and whether a proportionate response short of dismissal would protect safety.