World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
‘Trump bad, Biden good’ – Ask the people of Gaza if there’s any difference in practice between the two American presidents. But our establishment is happy to laud one, and sneer at the other…
The article argues that the common view of Donald Trump as harmful and Joe Biden as benevolent overlooks Biden’s support for Israel’s military campaign in Gaza. It contrasts the warm reception Biden received from Irish political figures during a Dublin visit with the author’s criticism of his record as US president.
The article cites estimates of more than 75,000 deaths in Gaza and 180,000 to 200,000 injuries, and says Biden-era US military aid to Israel reached €11.3 billion in 2024. It also claims that more than 47,000 Palestinians had been killed by January 2025, when Trump took office, and invokes Barack Obama’s response to chemical weapons use in Syria to argue that US presidents have all failed to prevent mass civilian suffering.
In short
- The article challenges the favourable portrayal of Biden compared with Trump.
- It cites high casualty estimates and extensive US military aid to Israel.
- It argues that US presidents have failed to prevent civilian suffering.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Biden’s defenders can argue that his support for Israel reflected a commitment to its security and to a longstanding US alliance, while his administration also pressed for humanitarian aid, civilian protection and ceasefire efforts. They may see his approach as an attempt to influence events through diplomacy and aid conditions, and consider Trump’s rhetoric and policies a greater risk to Palestinians and regional stability.
The case against
Critics can argue that continued US arms and diplomatic support materially enabled Israel’s campaign despite the scale of Palestinian deaths and injuries, making Biden’s calls for restraint inadequate in practice. From this view, praising him as benevolent while condemning Trump overlooks the consequences of policy continuity and the responsibility of both administrations for the suffering civilians endured.
Explained simply
The United States is Israel’s most important military ally, providing weapons and diplomatic support. Since the Hamas-led attacks on Israel in October 2023, Israel has waged a military campaign in Gaza, where large numbers of Palestinians have been killed and injured and homes and essential services have been destroyed.
Joe Biden was US president when the war began and continued US support for Israel during his term. Donald Trump succeeded him in January 2025. The article questions the contrast often drawn between the two presidents, and points to the role of US policy under several administrations in conflicts where civilians have suffered heavily.
The issue matters because US decisions on arms, aid and diplomacy can affect the course of the war and efforts to limit civilian harm. Irish politicians’ reception of Biden during a visit to Dublin is also part of the article’s focus on how political leaders’ public images compare with their policies.
Americas Government Middle East Politics World