Business news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Two new housing reports point to bleak winter ahead, with record low sales
Pending home sales in the US fell to their lowest level in the index’s 25-year history in October, signalling a weak finish to the year for housing transactions. The decline followed a September jump in mortgage rates and matters because signed contracts are an early indicator of completed sales.
Contracts fell 4.7% from September and 16.7% from a year earlier, despite a modest easing in mortgage rates during October. Single-family housing starts rose 4% month on month but were down 3.2% year on year, while building permits fell 8.7% and reached their lowest level since May 2020. Builders cited high costs, financing expenses and weak buyer demand; industry sentiment also reached a 14-year low in November.
In short
- Pending sales hit a 25-year index low.
- October contracts fell 16.7% year on year.
- Permits dropped to their lowest level since May 2020.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The figures suggest housing is becoming harder to access: record-low pending sales and weak buyer demand point to households being priced out by mortgage payments and other costs. Falling permits and builder confidence also raise concern that construction may not keep pace with future needs, while the year-on-year decline in starts suggests the market’s weakness is not confined to one month.
The case against
The reports show a serious slowdown, but they do not by themselves establish a lasting housing crisis: starts rose month on month, and mortgage rates eased somewhat in October. Builders facing high costs and uncertain demand may be acting prudently by limiting new projects, which could reduce the risk of oversupply and allow activity to recover if borrowing conditions improve.
Explained simply
The US housing market depends on buyers being able to afford home prices and mortgage payments, and on builders being willing to finance new construction. Mortgage rates affect the cost of borrowing, while materials, labour and other expenses shape the cost of building.
Pending home sales measure homes where a buyer and seller have signed a contract, before the sale is completed. They can offer an early indication of future sales, while housing starts and building permits show how much new construction is under way or planned.
Buyers, sellers and homebuilders are all affected by shifts in demand and costs. When fewer people can or choose to buy, builders may find it harder to justify new projects, which can influence the supply of homes over time.