Business news and discussion on TalkFuse.
UK banks struggle to find top boss to spearhead Visa and Mastercard alternative
Around 19 major UK financial services groups, including Barclays, Lloyds, NatWest and HSBC, are backing a new domestic payments network intended to rival Visa and Mastercard. The search for a permanent chief executive has been reopened after investors were dissatisfied with the final two candidates, delaying the appointment of a leader for the initiative.
The group, currently called the Payments Delivery Company, has sought to raise £50 million to fund its work through 2028. Barclays UK chief executive Vim Maru is acting as chair designate while the search continues, alongside interviews for board roles. The project is working with the Treasury and Bank of England, and the Bank’s Retail Payments Infrastructure Board is expected to publish its first formal blueprint in the first quarter of 2027.
In short
- UK banks have reopened their search for a payments network chief executive.
- The project aims to rival Visa and Mastercard.
- A formal blueprint is expected in early 2027.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
A domestic payments network could give the UK greater resilience and control over essential financial infrastructure, while reducing reliance on a small number of overseas card networks. With major banks backing the project and public bodies involved in planning, supporters can argue that patient investment now may create more choice and strengthen competition over time.
The case against
Building a rival network would require substantial funding and coordination, while consumers and businesses already rely on familiar, widely accepted payment systems. The difficulty finding a chief executive may reinforce concerns about execution and governance; sceptics can argue that the money and effort would be better spent improving existing services unless the project demonstrates clear benefits and a credible route to broad adoption.
Explained simply
Visa and Mastercard run card networks that help banks and shops process payments. UK banks and other financial groups are backing a proposed domestic network, currently called the Payments Delivery Company, which would provide another way to make payments in the UK.
The project is backed by about 19 groups, including Barclays, Lloyds, NatWest and HSBC, and is working with the Treasury and the Bank of England. Barclays UK chief executive Vim Maru is acting as chair designate. The Bank’s Retail Payments Infrastructure Board is expected to set out a formal blueprint in early 2027.
A domestic network could give UK payment providers an additional option alongside the established card networks. Its development depends on the participating groups agreeing how to organise and fund it, and on decisions about the infrastructure it would need.