World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Ukraine would trade territory for NATO membership, but Russia wouldn’t agree
President Volodymyr Zelensky said US negotiators asked whether Ukraine would withdraw from Donbas if it joined NATO, and he indicated Kyiv was open to discussing the idea. The article argues Russia would reject the proposed exchange, highlighting the difficulty of reaching a peace deal over Ukraine’s territory and security arrangements.
Moscow criticised Zelensky for disclosing the discussion, did not confirm that it took place, and reiterated its opposition to Ukraine joining NATO. The article also says Russia reportedly demanded that NATO expel Finland as part of any peace agreement, suggesting its objections extend beyond Ukraine’s membership.
In short
- Zelensky signalled openness to discussing a Donbas-for-NATO arrangement.
- Russia restated its opposition to Ukraine joining NATO.
- Moscow reportedly also demanded Finland leave the alliance.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Ukraine could consider relinquishing territory in exchange for NATO membership if it judged that a firm security guarantee and a durable end to the war would protect the rest of the country and save lives. Supporters of such a compromise might argue that any settlement must reflect what can realistically be secured, while leaving Ukrainians to decide whether the costs are acceptable.
The case against
Ukraine could reject trading territory for NATO membership because it would leave people and land under Russian control and might reward the use of force. Critics could also doubt whether membership would be secured or deter future attacks, and argue that a settlement made under wartime pressure risks weakening Ukraine’s sovereignty and long-term security.
Americas Europe Geopolitics Government Politics World