World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
US report warns Aukus submarine sales could weaken American fleet for years
A US Congressional Budget Office report warns that selling Virginia-class submarines to Australia under the Aukus agreement would reduce the number available to the US Navy for many years. It questions whether the transfer would weaken US undersea capability, and whether Australian submarines would necessarily join a US conflict with China.
The agreement provides for Australia to buy three to five US submarines from 2032. US shipyards currently build about 1.13 Virginia-class boats a year, compared with a target of two annually for US needs and 2.33 to also supply Australia; construction now takes an average of 10 to 11 years. US law allows a transfer only if it does not degrade US undersea capability, and the US can decline without penalty, although the deal retains bipartisan support in both countries.
In short
- US analysis warns submarine sales could reduce its fleet for years.
- Shipyards build 1.13 Virginia-class submarines annually.
- Australia would control its submarines and decide whether to deploy them.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Selling submarines to Australia could strengthen a long-term security partnership and help deter China by improving allied undersea capability in the Indo-Pacific. Australia’s access to Virginia-class boats could support shared operations, while the US retains the option to halt transfers if its own capability would be degraded.
The case against
With US shipyards building well below the rate needed to meet both American and Australian plans, transferring boats could leave the US Navy short for years when it considers undersea forces important to deterring China. The report also questions whether Australian submarines would necessarily be available in a US conflict, making the near-term cost to US readiness harder to justify.
Explained simply
Aukus is a security partnership between Australia, the UK and the US. Its submarine plan is intended to give Australia access to nuclear-powered submarines, which can travel long distances underwater without needing to surface as often as conventional boats.
The Virginia-class submarines in the plan are built for the US Navy, which also needs them for its own operations. US shipyards have been producing them more slowly than planned, and building each boat takes many years, so supplying Australia could affect how many are available to the US.
US law permits the transfer only if it does not weaken America’s undersea capability. The plan also raises questions about how Australia’s submarines would be used in a conflict involving China, and the agreement has support from both major parties in the countries involved.
Americas Asia Government Politics Software Technology World
Read the full article at the source →
Originally published by The Guardian as “US warned supplying nuclear-powered submarines to Australia would diminish its own fleet for ‘many years’”.