Entertainment news and discussion on TalkFuse.
‘Verity’ Review: Dakota Johnson and Anne Hathaway Drift Through Another Listless Colleen Hoover Adaptation
"Verity" is the fourth Colleen Hoover adaptation to reach cinemas, and it remains as critically unsuccessful as its predecessors in translating the novelist's bestselling work to screen. Directed by Michael Showalter, the film tells an unintentionally humorous tale of a struggling novelist hired to ghostwrite for a famous but incapacitated author, only to become entangled in dark mysteries. Despite the project's commercial potential—previous Hoover adaptations have collectively earned over half a billion dollars—the film struggles to justify the source material's popularity with audiences unfamiliar with Hoover's books.
The film suffers from flat pacing, overwrought plotting and a director ill-suited to the erotic thriller genre, leaving its impressive cast looking embarrassed or indifferent. Dakota Johnson, playing ghostwriter Lowen Ashleigh, embodies her trademark passive screen presence in a role that demands little nuance, whilst Anne Hathaway appears frozen in a part requiring only "glassy hauteur." Michael Showalter, who successfully directed Hathaway in the romantic comedy "The Idea of You," fumbles the material's high-camp melodrama and po-faced eroticism so badly that any humour emerges unintentionally, resulting in a film that feels simultaneously overwrought and narratively undernourished.
In short
- Fourth Hoover adaptation fails to capture source material's appeal despite half-billion-dollar franchise success
- Director Showalter mishandles erotic thriller genre with unintentional humour and poor pacing
- Strong cast appears disengaged; Johnson and Hathaway lack conviction in their roles
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Colleen Hoover adaptations clearly resonate with substantial audiences, as over half a billion dollars in box office earnings demonstrates. Rather than representing artistic failure, these films successfully serve their intended audience—fans of the books seeking to see stories they love adapted to screen. The critical establishment's sustained dismissal of commercially successful entertainment reflects cultural assumptions about what constitutes serious cinema rather than objective craft failure.
The case against
Filmmaking quality matters independently of commercial appeal; flat pacing, weak direction, and indifferent performances represent genuine technical failures that impede storytelling regardless of audience enthusiasm. The consistent critical failure across multiple well-funded adaptations suggests not critical snobbery toward popular fiction but systematic problems in execution. Films with substantial resources should engage both devoted fans and general audiences, and critical assessment serves an important function in identifying those failures.
Explained simply
Colleen Hoover is one of the world's bestselling authors, with millions of readers for her novels. Her books have recently become a focus for film adaptation, with previous movies collectively earning over half a billion dollars at the box office.
"Verity" is the fourth of Hoover's novels to be adapted for cinema. The story follows a struggling novelist hired to ghostwrite for a famous author who has become incapacitated, only to find herself entangled in dark mysteries surrounding her employer.
The film stars Dakota Johnson as the ghostwriter and Anne Hathaway as the famous author she ghostwrites for. It is directed by Michael Showalter, who has previously worked with Hathaway on other film projects.