World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
‘Very hot’ coffee and tea linked to higher cancer risk in nearly 1 million adults
A large University of Oxford study has found that regularly drinking tea or coffee at very high temperatures is linked to a substantially higher risk of oesophageal squamous cell carcinoma (SCC), a cancer affecting the cells lining the gullet. Researchers said people who described their drinks as "very hot" had around three times the risk of developing SCC compared with those who preferred warm beverages, while drinking six or more hot drinks daily raised the risk by 71%. The link was not observed for oesophageal adenocarcinoma, a different type of oesophageal cancer, and experts say the findings support advice to let hot drinks cool slightly rather than avoid them altogether.
The research, published in the International Journal of Cancer, drew on data from nearly one million UK adults across the Million Women Study and UK Biobank, followed for an average of 14 and 11 years respectively, making it the largest study of its kind. Compared with "warm" drinkers, those who drank beverages "hot" had a 1.7 times higher SCC risk, rising to threefold for "very hot" drinkers, and researchers estimate around 14% of SCC cases could be prevented if people drank beverages hot rather than very hot. A key limitation is that temperatures were self-reported rather than measured, and an outside specialist noted that SCC accounts for only a small share of oesophageal cancers in the US, with a lifetime risk of under 1%, and is caused by repeated thermal injury similar to a burn.
In short
- Very hot tea/coffee linked to triple the risk of oesophageal SCC.
- Study of nearly 1 million UK adults is largest of its kind.
- Experts advise letting drinks cool slightly rather than quitting them.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The findings support taking very hot drinks seriously as a preventable risk: the study followed nearly a million adults over many years and found a clear association between reported drink temperature and oesophageal SCC. Letting drinks cool slightly is a modest precaution that may reduce repeated heat injury without requiring people to give up tea or coffee.
The case against
The evidence does not establish that very hot drinks cause SCC: temperature was self-reported, and other factors could partly explain the association. The risk concerns one type of oesophageal cancer, which is uncommon in some populations, and the findings do not show a link to another major type; they therefore support caution in interpreting the size and wider significance of the risk.
Explained simply
The gullet, also called the oesophagus, is the tube that carries food and drink from the mouth to the stomach. Oesophageal cancer can begin in different kinds of cells lining this tube; squamous cell carcinoma (SCC) is one type, while adenocarcinoma is another.
The study drew on two large UK research groups, the Million Women Study and UK Biobank, which follow adults’ health over time. It looked at how people described the temperature of their tea and coffee and whether they later developed either type of cancer.
The research concerns a possible link between repeated heat exposure and damage to the gullet’s lining. SCC is only one form of oesophageal cancer, so findings about it do not necessarily apply to other forms.
Americas Health Medicine Research Science World