Week 9 AP Top 25 Poll makes a mockery of Wake Forest and a laughable overreaction to USC’s win over Buckeyes
USC’s win over Ohio State drove a sharp rise in the Week 9 AP Top 25, while unbeaten Wake Forest stayed at No. 14 despite a dominant run. The article argues voters overreacted to USC’s result and undervalued Wake Forest, raising questions about how much the poll reflects teams’ overall records and performances.
Miami, Georgia, Utah, Notre Dame and UCLA make up the poll’s top five, though the article says UCLA has a stronger case than Utah for third and Notre Dame is ranked too high. Wake Forest is 7-1 after beating Virginia 51-7, and has outscored opponents 187-31 over its last four weeks; its only loss was to top-ranked Miami. USC rose 13 places to No. 18 after beating Ohio State, which was without its starting quarterback, despite recent losses to Wisconsin and Oregon.
In short
- USC jumped 13 places to No. 18 after beating Ohio State.
- Wake Forest stayed at No. 14 despite a 7-1 record.
- The article criticises voters’ treatment of both teams.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
USC’s win over Ohio State was a high-profile result against a highly regarded opponent, and voters may reasonably have treated it as evidence that USC is stronger than its recent losses suggested. Polls also weigh the quality and context of wins, so Ohio State missing its starting quarterback need not erase the significance of the victory. Wake Forest’s strong record and recent dominance support a higher ranking, but its schedule may give voters reason to place it below teams with more demanding résumés.
The case against
A 13-place jump for USC may overvalue one result, particularly given its losses to Wisconsin and Oregon and Ohio State’s absence of its starting quarterback. Wake Forest is 7-1, with its sole defeat to top-ranked Miami, and its recent scoring margin suggests sustained performance rather than a single standout win. Voters who prioritise the full season’s results and consistency could therefore argue Wake Forest deserves a higher place than USC.
Explained simply
The AP Top 25 is a weekly ranking of the leading teams in US college football, voted for by a panel of sports writers and broadcasters. Voters weigh teams’ results and performances, but the poll is a judgement rather than a calculation based on one fixed formula.
Wake Forest, USC and Ohio State are university teams in the top level of college football. Their records, recent results and the strength of their opponents all help shape how voters assess them; a team’s ranking can therefore differ from what its win-loss record alone might suggest.
Rankings can influence public perceptions of which teams are strongest and shape discussion about the season. Comparing a team’s full run of results with the attention given to a high-profile win helps explain why poll positions are debated.
Americas Elections Health Medicine Politics World