Health news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Welcome to Melbourne in 2026: Man ‘smokes meth’ in broad daylight as critics claim law change lets druggies ‘get away with it’
A video appearing to show a nearly naked man smoking methamphetamine on a Preston footpath has reignited debate about public drug use and crime in Melbourne. Critics argue Victoria’s approach to public intoxication has weakened enforcement, while the episode raises questions about how police should respond to suspected drug offences and people in distress.
Victoria decriminalised public intoxication in November 2023, replacing automatic criminal penalties with a health-based response, partly over concerns about the treatment of vulnerable people, particularly Indigenous Australians. The reform did not legalise methamphetamine possession or use, and police retain powers to investigate suspected drug offences. Social commentator Prue MacSween criticised the police and justice system, but her claims about safety and enforcement are opinions rather than evidence presented in the article.
In short
- Video appears to show meth use on a Melbourne footpath.
- Victoria changed public intoxication laws in 2023.
- The reform did not legalise illicit drug use.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
A health-based response to public intoxication can reduce harm to vulnerable people, including Indigenous Australians, who may be poorly served by automatic arrest and criminal penalties. The reform did not legalise methamphetamine use, and police can still investigate suspected drug offences; a person who appears intoxicated or in distress may need health support as well as an appropriate law-enforcement response.
The case against
People concerned about public drug use can argue that visible incidents may make residents feel unsafe and that laws need to be enforced consistently to maintain confidence in public spaces. Even though the reform did not legalise methamphetamine use, they may question whether police and other services have clear, effective ways to respond to suspected offences and distress under a health-based approach.