Business news and discussion on TalkFuse.
While the headlines rave about Milburn’s Neets review, the young people I know are angry and frustrated | Felicity Halstead
Youth charity leader Felicity Halstead says young people are frustrated that responses to high youth unemployment focus on welfare reform and benefit entitlements, rather than making the jobs market fairer. She welcomes Alan Milburn’s recognition that the system has failed young people, but argues his review’s proposals may not create decent opportunities quickly or widely enough.
A round table with young people and employers found that entry-level jobs are hard to access without experience, while employers cited hiring costs, AI-generated applications and concerns about legal claims when giving feedback. The review proposes guarantees of college places, training, apprenticeships, work experience or jobs, as well as lower employer National Insurance contributions and more apprenticeships. Halstead says the measures may offer limited choice, and notes that 15% of young people not in employment, education or training have degrees.
In short
- Young people want a fairer jobs market, not just welfare reform.
- Milburn’s review proposes guarantees of training, experience or work.
- Halstead questions whether the measures are broad or fast enough.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The review recognises that the system has failed many young people and proposes practical routes into work, including training, apprenticeships, work experience and college places. Lower employer National Insurance contributions and more apprenticeships could encourage hiring and help young people gain the experience employers often require.
The case against
Young people’s difficulties may stem less from benefit rules than from an entry-level jobs market that demands experience and offers too few decent opportunities. Guarantees of training or placements may provide limited choice and do little to widen access quickly, especially for graduates also struggling to find work; reform should address employers’ hiring practices and the quality and availability of jobs.
Explained simply
“Young people not in employment, education or training” is often shortened to “NEET”. The term covers people in different situations, including those looking for work, studying or unable to take part because of health or caring responsibilities.
Alan Milburn’s review examines why many young people struggle to find work or training. Its proposals include guarantees of college places, apprenticeships, work experience or jobs, alongside changes intended to encourage employers to hire.
The debate is about whether these measures can lead to enough decent opportunities, and how much responsibility lies with young people, employers and government. Entry-level jobs can be difficult to get without experience, while some young people who are NEET already have degrees.
Business Companies Economy Politics