New releases, music videos and album news — indie, rap, rock and pop. Always covering Ren, Chris Webby, Sam Tompkins, bbno$, CHINCHILLA, Muse, Yungblud and more.
Who really wrote The Beatles’ 1965 track ‘In My Life’?
A Far Out Magazine feature revisits the long-running dispute between John Lennon and Paul McCartney over who was primarily responsible for writing "In My Life," a track from the Beatles' 1965 album Rubber Soul. Despite being credited jointly under the Lennon-McCartney partnership, the two men gave conflicting accounts in later years about who wrote the song's lyrics and melody, making it one of the most debated authorship cases in the band's catalogue.
Lennon maintained that he wrote the song largely on his own, describing the lyrics as autobiographical reflections on his childhood and Liverpool upbringing, while McCartney has claimed a more significant role in composing the music, particularly the melody. The unresolved disagreement, which persisted through interviews the pair gave separately over the decades, reflects the wider difficulty of untangling individual contributions within one of music's most celebrated songwriting partnerships.
In short
- Lennon and McCartney gave conflicting accounts of writing "In My Life"
- Lennon claimed the lyrics and much of the song as his own
- McCartney has said he wrote a significant part of the melody
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Lennon's claim rests on the song's undeniably autobiographical lyrics, which reflect his personal childhood memories and emotional connection to Liverpool. He maintained consistently across multiple interviews over decades that he wrote the song largely on his own, a significant testament to his recollection. The lyrical substance—the reflective exploration of his formative years—forms the emotional core of the piece and represents genuine creative authorship.
The case against
McCartney's contribution to the song's composition, particularly the melody, constitutes a substantial creative achievement that should not be minimised. The melody is what gives the song its distinctive character and memorability; musical composition is equally important to lyrical composition in defining a song's identity. His claim to significant credit for the musical elements represents a legitimate form of authorship that deserves recognition alongside lyrical contributions.
Explained simply
"In My Life" is a Beatles song released in 1965 on their album Rubber Soul. For decades, John Lennon and Paul McCartney have disagreed about who was primarily responsible for writing it, even though it carries both their names as composers.
Lennon maintained he wrote the song largely by himself, emphasising that the lyrics were his own autobiographical reflections on his childhood and Liverpool upbringing. McCartney, however, claimed a more significant role in composing the music and melody, leaving the true authorship unresolved between them.
This dispute reflects the broader difficulty in untangling individual contributions within the Lennon-McCartney partnership, one of pop music's most celebrated songwriting teams. The two men gave conflicting accounts in separate interviews over the years, making it one of the most debated authorship questions in the Beatles' catalogue.