Politics news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Why Exactly Does The Supreme Court “Deserve Our Celebration”?
The article argues that Supreme Court independence should not be measured simply by whether conservative justices rule against President Trump. It challenges a recent defence of the Court’s record, saying that highlighting cases in which Trump lost overlooks conservative justices who supported him and Trump-appointed justices who dissented from one another.
The piece says Justices Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alito backed Trump in the cases cited, while Neil Gorsuch, Brett Kavanaugh and Amy Coney Barrett sometimes disagreed with other conservative justices. It also cites Justice Elena Kagan’s description of the chief justice working with a shifting group of colleagues to check the executive branch. The author argues that these mixed votes make the Court’s record more complicated than a tally of Trump’s wins and losses.
In short
- Trump’s losses alone do not prove the Supreme Court is independent.
- Conservative justices have split over cases involving his administration.
- The article argues independence should be judged by legal reasoning.