World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Why Harry Shum Jr.’s shocking ‘DWTS’ elimination was written on the wall
Harry Shum Jr. and Jenna Johnson were eliminated from *Dancing With the Stars* one week after Jenna Dewan and Val Chmerkovskiy, prompting debate about whether viewers were tiring of contestants with professional dance backgrounds and the show’s pairings. The article argues that both factors, alongside resentment over established pros receiving strong partners, may have contributed to the exits.
Shum Jr. and Dewan had worked as professional dancers before acting, while Johnson has won twice and Chmerkovskiy three times. Some fans had wanted Shum Jr. paired with Britt Stewart, who has never won and is the show’s only Black female professional dancer in its 21-year history. Chmerkovskiy was also suspended for a week after posting a comment that many interpreted as a joking threat towards judge Carrie Ann Inaba; Alan Bersten stepped in as Johnson’s partner during that period. The finale is scheduled for 24 November.
In short
- Harry Shum Jr. and Jenna Johnson left the competition.
- Fans questioned the show’s pairings and contestant dance experience.
- Chmerkovskiy’s social media comment added to the controversy.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Viewers may reasonably see the eliminations as a way to preserve the show’s appeal as a competition about growth, effort and connection, rather than professional technique alone. Pairing already accomplished dancers with decorated professionals can seem to give them an advantage, while choosing a less experienced partner such as Britt Stewart could offer a fairer opportunity and greater representation. Fan reactions may therefore reflect a desire for suspense and a level playing field.
The case against
A contestant’s professional dance experience does not necessarily make them an unfair competitor: the show also tests adaptability, performance and rapport, and audiences may enjoy seeing a skilled dancer take on new styles. Experienced professional partners can help contestants deliver compelling routines, and past wins do not guarantee current success. The exits may also reflect individual performances, voting preferences or the controversy around the pairings, so they do not by themselves establish broad viewer fatigue.
Explained simply
Dancing With the Stars pairs celebrities with professional dancers, who help them learn routines for weekly performances. Viewers score the couples, and public votes also help decide who stays; the programme has run for more than two decades.
Harry Shum Jr. and Jenna Dewan had dance experience before becoming actors, while their professional partners, Jenna Johnson and Val Chmerkovskiy, are multiple-time winners. Britt Stewart is the show’s only Black female professional dancer and has yet to win, leading some viewers to question how the pairings are made.
The exits have renewed debate about whether dance experience and the choice of professional partner affect how viewers vote. Chmerkovskiy’s temporary suspension after a comment about judge Carrie Ann Inaba added another point of discussion around the partnerships.