World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Manhattan judge released man with 38 arrests a day before fatal attack
Alexander Florentino was released under supervision by a Manhattan judge on Thursday, despite prosecutors seeking bail and his record of 38 arrests, five pending cases and missed court appearances. The next day, he allegedly entered a Chinatown apartment, sexually assaulted and killed a 64-year-old woman, and injured her roommate.
Prosecutors say the roommate interrupted the attack and was struck with a beer bottle and nearly strangled; he was hospitalised with a brain haemorrhage and facial injuries. Florentino allegedly fled, tried to enter another flat and was later arrested after a rooftop chase. He had also been released days earlier in a separate case, prompting a New York City councilman to criticise the decisions and call for tighter bail rules.
In short
- Florentino was released a day before the alleged fatal attack.
- He had 38 prior arrests and five pending cases.
- A councilman called for tighter bail rules.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The judge may have been applying bail rules that limit detention before trial, especially when charges remain unproven and release conditions can be imposed. A high arrest count alone does not establish guilt, and safeguards against unnecessary pre-trial detention protect the presumption of innocence and reduce unequal burdens on people who cannot afford bail.
The case against
Prosecutors could argue that the pending cases, repeated missed court appearances and pattern of arrests indicated a serious risk to public safety and failure to return to court. They may say that supervision was not adequate in these circumstances, and that bail rules should allow detention when specific evidence shows a substantial risk of further serious harm.
Explained simply
New York’s bail system determines whether someone charged with a crime stays in custody while their case proceeds. Judges weigh factors set out in law, and release under supervision can require a person to check in or follow other conditions; an arrest record is not the same as a conviction.
Prosecutors can ask a judge to keep a defendant in custody, but the judge makes the decision under the rules that apply to the case. The debate over bail in New York concerns how those rules balance a defendant’s freedom before trial with public safety and the need for people to attend court.
Read the full article at the source →
Originally published by Daily Mail as “Woke judge released thug with 38 prior arrests just one day before he broke into woman’s apartment and murdered her”.