Woman collapses during public caning for sex outside marriage in Aceh
A woman collapsed during a public caning in Banda Aceh after being convicted of sex outside marriage under Sharia law. She was among eight people sentenced by the Banda Aceh Syar’iyah Court, and the incident has renewed attention on a punishment that human rights groups condemn as cruel and degrading.
Aceh is Indonesia’s only province to apply Islamic law in practice, and caning is used for offences including adultery, gambling and drinking alcohol. Sentences can reach 100 lashes, delivered in public to inflict pain and shame; officials defend the practice as a deterrent and part of the province’s identity, while critics say it causes lasting harm and breaches human rights standards.
- A woman collapsed during a public caning in Banda Aceh.
- Eight people were sentenced for violating Aceh’s Islamic laws.
- Rights groups say public caning is cruel and degrading.
New here? Start with this
Aceh is a province at the western end of Indonesia and the only one where Islamic law is enforced through local rules. Its religious courts can sentence people for offences such as sex outside marriage, gambling and drinking alcohol.
Caning is one of the punishments set out in those rules. It is carried out in public, and sentences can reach 100 strokes. Local officials describe it as a deterrent and part of Aceh’s identity; human rights groups argue that it causes harm and violates human rights standards.
Both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Supporters argue that Aceh’s elected authorities may enforce locally established religious law, and that public caning reflects community values while deterring conduct the law prohibits. They may also regard a defined judicial sentence as a more accountable form of punishment than arbitrary enforcement, provided procedures are followed and the person’s safety is protected.
The case against
Critics argue that deliberately inflicting pain and public humiliation is cruel and degrading, and that a person collapsing underscores the risk of physical and lasting psychological harm. They contend that local tradition or deterrence cannot justify punishment that conflicts with human rights protections, especially when it targets private consensual conduct.
Cybersecurity Technology World
Read the full article at the source →
Originally published by Daily Mail as “Woman collapses after being caned for sex outside marriage in breach of Sharia law in Indonesia”.