World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Woman’s Bumble date went so badly wrong she now carries a gun, after man she met was jailed thanks to ‘Are we dating the same guy?’ Facebook group
An Oregon woman says a Bumble date with Nicholas Michael Donohue became non-consensual, and that the experience led her to carry a gun when dating. Her account is separate from the cases that resulted in Donohue being jailed, which police began investigating after a woman posted about him in an “Are we dating the same guy?” Facebook group.
Police opened four cases following reports from women who said they had met Donohue through dating apps and experienced abusive behaviour. He pleaded guilty to two counts of coercion, fourth-degree assault involving domestic violence and attempted coercion, and was sentenced on 4 November to 70 days in jail and three years’ supervised probation. He was acquitted of first-degree sexual abuse and kidnapping charges; his lawyer denied the newer allegations.
In short
- An Oregon woman says a Bumble date became non-consensual.
- Donohue was sentenced to 70 days in jail after pleading guilty to four offences.
- Police investigations followed reports shared through a dating safety Facebook group.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Supporters of “Are we dating the same guy?” groups argue that sharing first-hand accounts can alert others to alleged patterns of abuse, help people make informed choices and prompt authorities to investigate concerns that might otherwise remain isolated. In this case, police opened cases after reports from women, and Donohue was convicted of several offences, though the woman’s Bumble-date account was separate from those cases.
The case against
Critics argue that naming people in informal online groups can spread unverified allegations, damage reputations and bypass safeguards that courts use to assess evidence and hear responses. They may also worry that fear-driven responses, such as carrying a gun on dates, can create additional risks; this concern can coexist with taking women’s safety reports seriously and recognising Donohue’s convictions.
Explained simply
Bumble is a dating app that helps people meet potential partners. Some users also share warnings and ask for information in Facebook groups called “Are we dating the same guy?”, where members discuss men they have dated.
In this case, police investigated reports from four women who said they had met Nicholas Michael Donohue through dating apps and experienced abusive behaviour. Donohue pleaded guilty to several charges and was sentenced to jail and supervised probation; he was acquitted of other charges, and his lawyer denied the newer allegations.
The Oregon woman’s account of her date is separate from the cases that led to his sentence. Her experience highlights the personal safety concerns some people face when dating and the role online groups can play in sharing information.