World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Yoga chiefs slam Olympic bid for ancient practice: ‘Gold medals are at odds with its spiritual foundations’
India plans to ask the International Olympic Committee to include yogasana, a competitive discipline based on yoga postures, at the 2036 Games. The proposal has drawn criticism from yoga traditionalists, who say competition and medals conflict with yoga’s spiritual aims, while supporters argue that the sport could attract wider interest.
Yoga Scotland trustee Michelle Cooke said postures are only one part of a practice centred on awareness and meditation, and warned that elite competition could make yoga seem accessible only to people with exceptional strength or flexibility. The International Yoga Sports Federation supports Olympic inclusion; London-based instructor Laura McDonald says yogasana is distinct from yoga as a whole and that competitions have roots in India dating to the 1970s. Ahmedabad is among six cities being considered to host the 2036 Games.
In short
- India plans to seek Olympic inclusion for competitive yogasana.
- Yoga Scotland says medals conflict with yoga’s spiritual aims.
- Supporters see yogasana as a distinct competitive discipline.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Supporters can argue that yogasana is a distinct competitive discipline focused on postures, rather than an attempt to reduce yoga as a whole to sport. Olympic inclusion could introduce more people to the practice, and competitions have a history in India dating back to the 1970s.
The case against
Traditionalists can argue that yoga’s postures are only one part of a broader practice centred on awareness and meditation, so awarding medals risks misrepresenting its spiritual aims. Elite competition could also make yoga appear to require exceptional strength or flexibility, discouraging people who might otherwise see it as accessible.
Explained simply
Yoga is a practice that includes physical postures, breathing, meditation and ways of cultivating awareness. Yogasana refers specifically to performing yoga postures as a competitive sport, with participants judged against one another.
India’s proposal concerns adding yogasana to the Olympic programme, which is decided by the International Olympic Committee. The debate reflects different views of yoga: some practitioners see competition as separate from its spiritual aims, while supporters see it as a way to bring the sport to a wider audience.
The issue matters because Olympic status could raise yogasana’s profile and influence how people understand yoga. Ahmedabad is one of six cities being considered to host the 2036 Games.