Culture news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Nathan Fielder probes Elizabeth Holmes in unsettling documentary
Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim’s film brings convicted Theranos founder Elizabeth Holmes into close conversation with Fielder before she went to prison. The review describes it as a gripping, unsettling blend of documentary and staged reality, built around Fielder’s effort to understand whether Holmes recognises the gap between her claims and the truth.
Holmes continues to say she is innocent and maintains that Theranos’s blood-testing technology could work, while Fielder questions her alongside her partner, Billy Evans. The film revisits the company’s 2003 claim that a small device could diagnose many illnesses from a drop of blood, and includes a striking midpoint twist that the review advises viewers to experience without prior details.
In short
- Nathan Fielder’s film examines Elizabeth Holmes before prison.
- Holmes still insists she is innocent and that Theranos could work.
- The documentary blends intimate conversations with staged reality.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
A close, carefully constructed conversation may help viewers understand how Holmes sees herself and whether she recognises the distance between her claims and the evidence. By combining direct questioning with staged reality, the film can probe conviction, self-deception and accountability in ways a conventional account might not.
The case against
The blend of documentary and staged reality may blur what is observed and what is engineered, making it harder for viewers to judge Holmes or the filmmakers’ conclusions fairly. Given her conviction and continued claims of innocence, a film framed around testing her self-understanding risks turning a complex case into a spectacle or implying certainty about her inner motives.
Read the full article at the source →
Originally published by The Guardian as “You Can See Everything review – unblinking, unhinged and unmissable”.