Entertainment news and discussion on TalkFuse.
“Your voice reminds me of Roger Waters”: The Van Halen song Eddie needed persuading to sing
Eddie Van Halen was reluctant to sing “How Many Say I”, a track on Van Halen’s 1998 album *Van Halen III*, but bandmate Gary Cherone encouraged him to record it. Cherone recalled telling Van Halen that his voice reminded him of Roger Waters and Leonard Cohen. The episode highlights the band’s difficult transition after Sammy Hagar’s departure and the different roles its singers played.
The article describes “How Many Say I” as one of the band’s least popular songs on streaming services, and characterises Van Halen’s reception of Cherone-era work as mixed. Cherone had been the singer in Extreme, but the article argues that the group’s attempt to follow Hagar’s powerful vocals was a poor fit. Van Halen III gave Eddie greater control, yet his subdued, talk-sung performance on this track drew attention to how much the band’s sound depended on its frontmen and Michael Anthony’s backing vocals.
In short
- Cherone persuaded Eddie to sing “How Many Say I”.
- He compared Eddie’s voice with Roger Waters and Leonard Cohen.
- The track remains among Van Halen’s least popular on streaming services.
Explained simply
Van Halen are an American rock band built around guitarist Eddie Van Halen and drummer Alex Van Halen. Their singers helped shape the group’s sound: Sammy Hagar replaced original frontman David Lee Roth in 1985, then left in 1996. Gary Cherone, previously the singer in the band Extreme, joined for the 1998 album Van Halen III.
The change in singers brought a change in vocal style, while bassist Michael Anthony’s backing vocals had also been a distinctive part of the band’s sound. On Van Halen III, Eddie Van Halen took a larger role in shaping the music and sang lead on one track. How the group adapted to its new line-up helps explain the mixed response to this period of its career.