17 Years Later, This 20-Minute Opener Is Still Better Than Every World War II Movie Since
An opinion piece argues that *Inglourious Basterds* has one of the most effective opening sequences in any World War II film. It says Quentin Tarantino’s carefully paced tension establishes the film’s central conflict and makes the scene’s impact linger long after it ends.
The sequence centres on Nazi officer Hans Landa questioning French dairy farmer Perrier LaPadite at his home, while Shosanna Dreyfus and her family hide beneath the floorboards. Christoph Waltz’s performance as Landa is presented as crucial to the scene’s menace; the article notes that Tarantino nearly shelved the film before casting him. Though other war films may surpass it in other respects, the piece says none begins with quite the same force.
In short
- The article praises *Inglourious Basterds*’ tense opening.
- Hans Landa’s interrogation drives the scene.
- Christoph Waltz’s performance is key to its impact.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The opening earns its reputation through deliberate pacing, precise dialogue and Christoph Waltz’s unsettling performance, turning a quiet interrogation into a sustained study of fear. By introducing the film’s central conflict and leaving Shosanna’s family’s fate hanging beneath the floorboards, it creates an impact that many later war films’ openings do not match.
The case against
A powerful opening does not make a film’s beginning objectively better than every later World War II movie’s; that judgement depends on taste and on what an opening is meant to achieve. Some viewers may value historical realism, emotional breadth or an immediate sense of combat, and other films can excel by those measures even if they build tension differently.
Americas Entertainment Film World