MATT CALKINS: Megan Rapinoe defends biological males in women’s sports saying sports were not meant to be fair
Megan Rapinoe defended transgender women’s participation in women’s sport in an interview with comedian W. Kamau Bell, arguing that sport is inherently unfair and that access to play and human rights matter more than perceived competitive advantages. The article criticises her position and argues that it overlooks fairness and the experiences of female athletes.
Rapinoe said transgender athletes cannot simply declare themselves women and enter competition, and dismissed the idea that a high-profile male athlete might do so. The writer cites a Washington high-school runner who moved from the boys’ to the girls’ team and reportedly won one varsity race and placed second in three others. The supplied article ends mid-sentence, so it does not include the writer’s final point.
In short
- Rapinoe says sport is not inherently fair.
- She supports transgender women’s participation in women’s sport.
- The article cites a Washington runner’s race results.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Supporters of including transgender women argue that sport is not perfectly fair even among female athletes, and that blanket exclusion can deny people the health, community and dignity that come with participation. They favour rules that let transgender people compete while addressing any sport-specific advantage through evidence-based eligibility standards, rather than treating identity alone as decisive.
The case against
Critics argue that women’s categories exist to preserve meaningful opportunities for female athletes, whose competitive outcomes can be affected by sex-linked physical differences. They say inclusion rules should give substantial weight to fairness and safety, and that policies should be grounded in evidence about the sport and level of competition rather than assuming all advantages are trivial.
Explained simply
Megan Rapinoe is a former United States footballer who has spoken publicly about transgender people’s rights and their place in sport. Transgender women are women whose gender identity differs from the sex they were assigned at birth; sporting bodies set rules for whether and how they can compete in women’s events.
The debate centres on how to balance inclusion and access to sport with competitive fairness and the experiences of female athletes. Rules differ between sports and organisations, and arguments often focus on whether factors linked to sex affect performance after someone transitions.
The article refers to a Washington state school running case as an example in this debate. School competitions are governed by their own eligibility rules, which may differ from those used in elite sport.