World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Coroner rules Birmingham teenager Mark Billington was unlawfully killed in 1984
A coroner has ruled that 15-year-old Mark Billington was unlawfully killed, overturning the original view that his 1984 death was suicide. His family had long believed he was murdered and are seeking an apology from West Midlands Police, whose early handling of the case, they say, damaged the chance of finding his killer.
Mark disappeared in Yardley, Birmingham, after going out on his bike and was found nine weeks later in a copse near Solihull. The inquest heard that he was found hanging with an unusual three-knot rope system, which a pathologist said he was unlikely to have tied himself; he also had weakness on his left side. Police reopened the case as a murder investigation in 2002 and arrested three men, but no one was charged; the rope and some clothing had been discarded.
In short
- Coroner rules Mark Billington was unlawfully killed.
- His family says police mishandling cost opportunities to find the killer.
- The 15-year-old disappeared in 1984 and was found nine weeks later.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The coroner’s ruling and evidence about the unusual knots and Mark’s physical weakness support the family’s long-held view that his death was not suicide. They can reasonably argue that the early investigation fell short, that discarded evidence may have hindered efforts to identify whoever killed him, and that the police should acknowledge any failings and apologise.
The case against
An unlawful killing ruling establishes that Mark was killed by someone else, but it does not identify the killer or, by itself, establish that police misconduct caused the case to remain unsolved. A fair assessment of the force’s early handling should distinguish documented errors from what investigators could reasonably have known in 1984, while recognising that an apology may be warranted only once those failings are clearly established.
Read the full article at the source →
Originally published by Daily Mail as “Sister’s anger after coroner finally rules brother was unlawfully killed – 42 years after police officers dismissed the case as a suicide and threw away crucial evidence”.