Politics news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Oxford Reform Society president accused over antisemitic writings
Oxford University’s Reform Society president, Vittorio Cuneo-Flood, has been accused of antisemitism after writings he published in a Catholic newsletter in 2024 described the “Jewish nation” as aligned with Satan and called antisemitism a “false notion”. The remarks have renewed scrutiny of the society and its plans to host speakers whose views have drawn criticism.
Cuneo-Flood, a fourth-year classics student, became president this year after joining Oxford in 2023. The Recusant is linked to the Society of Saint Pius X, which includes Holocaust denier Richard Williamson. The society is also hosting Reform MP Andrew Rosindell and activist Lucy White, while a planned Oxford talk by academic Nathan Cofnas has prompted objections, a letter of support from more than 170 academics and a demonstration planned by Stand Up to Racism. Cuneo-Flood declined to comment on his articles.
In short
- Oxford Reform Society president faces accusations over antisemitic writings.
- His 2024 newsletter articles targeted Jews and disputed antisemitism.
- The society’s speaker events have also drawn protests and academic support.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The published remarks provide a reasonable basis for concern: describing Jews collectively as aligned with Satan and dismissing antisemitism can be seen as antisemitic, particularly given the newsletter’s association with a group that includes a Holocaust denier. Students may argue that the society should consider whether its president’s public writings and speaker choices make Jewish members feel unwelcome and undermine trust in the organisation.
The case against
A fair assessment should distinguish the reported quotations from the author’s full context and should not assume that association with a publication or a controversial group proves a person’s own beliefs. The society may also argue that hosting contentious speakers is legitimate academic and political debate, and that criticism should address specific statements and conduct rather than become a presumption of guilt or a reason to shut down discussion.
Explained simply
Oxford’s Reform Society is a student group that organises political discussions and invites speakers. Its president, Vittorio Cuneo-Flood, is a classics student who joined the university in 2023. The society has also faced scrutiny over some of the speakers it plans to host.
The controversy concerns articles Cuneo-Flood published in 2024 in The Recusant, a Catholic newsletter linked to the Society of Saint Pius X. The newsletter has included material by Richard Williamson, a bishop who has denied the Holocaust. The articles’ remarks about Jewish people and antisemitism have drawn criticism.
The issue matters because university societies provide forums for public debate, while decisions about speakers can prompt disagreement over what views should be heard. Planned events involving other speakers have also drawn objections and public support, bringing further attention to the society.
Read the full article at the source →
Originally published by Daily Mail as “Reform’s society head at Oxford said Jews are working with Satan and that anti-Semitism was a ‘false notion’”.