World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
The Patrick Mahomes reason why Raiders fans have no worry about Fernando Mendoza
Raiders quarterback Fernando Mendoza lost his first NFL start as Seattle’s defence sacked him six times, but the performance should be viewed in the context of how effectively the Seahawks have troubled other young quarterbacks and even Patrick Mahomes. The game exposed areas for Mendoza to improve, while offering a demanding first lesson against a defence led by Mike Macdonald.
Mendoza completed 17 of 29 passes for 143 yards, after completing 11 of 13 to eight receivers in the first half; tight end Brock Bowers left with an ankle injury early on. Mendoza said he sometimes should have stayed in the pocket for one more beat, while coach Klint Kubiak accepted responsibility for the Raiders’ failure to convert any of seven third downs in the second half. Bo Nix and Caleb Williams also struggled against Seattle as rookies, and Mahomes had a 58.3 passer rating against the defence three weeks earlier.
In short
- Seattle’s defence made Mendoza’s debut a difficult test.
- Mendoza completed 17 of 29 passes for 143 yards.
- He identified pocket decisions as a key area to improve.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
One difficult debut against Seattle’s highly disruptive defence is weak evidence that Mendoza is not ready: other young quarterbacks struggled against the same unit, and even Patrick Mahomes posted a low passer rating. Mendoza showed promise in the first half, while the loss of Brock Bowers and the team’s failure to convert second-half third downs also shaped the result; his own comments suggest he recognises what to improve. A demanding first start can therefore be treated as a learning experience rather than a reason for Raiders fans to lose confidence.
The case against
The defeat still offers concrete reasons for concern: Mendoza was sacked six times, managed only 143 passing yards, and the Raiders failed to convert any of seven second-half third downs. His strong first half did not carry through the rest of the game, and his own observation that he should sometimes have stayed in the pocket points to an area that needs work. Seattle’s success against other quarterbacks provides context, but it does not establish how Mendoza will respond or remove the need to assess his performance on its own.