World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
CUNY under fire after student gov leaders suddenly scrap ‘cultural night’ involving Jewish group
Hunter College student leaders cancelled a planned “Cultural Arts Night” involving several campus groups, including Hunter Hillel, prompting criticism and a call for a federal investigation. Democratic city councilman Eric Dinowitz said Jewish students were being excluded because of their identity, while advocates argued Hillel’s inclusion may have prompted the cancellation.
The Student Government Association’s statement apologised for including certain groups and said future event partners would be identified before approval, but did not name Hillel. The Hillel chapter said it had no role in the cancellation and condemned both antisemitism and hostile online responses. The dispute comes amid earlier federal findings that Hunter did not properly investigate antisemitism complaints and a 2024 settlement addressing nine discrimination complaints against CUNY, including allegations of antisemitism and Islamophobia.
In short
- Hunter student leaders cancelled a cultural event involving Hillel.
- A councilman called for a federal investigation.
- The dispute follows earlier federal findings and a CUNY settlement.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Critics argue that cancelling an event involving Hillel, alongside an apology for including some groups, raises a credible concern that Jewish students were excluded because of their identity. Given prior findings and complaints about CUNY’s handling of discrimination, they say an independent investigation could establish what drove the decision and whether students were treated consistently.
The case against
Others argue that the available account does not establish why student leaders cancelled the event or that Hillel’s Jewish identity was the reason; Hillel itself said it had no role in the cancellation. They may view the apology and plan to identify partners earlier as evidence of a student-group decision-making dispute, and caution that attributing antisemitic intent without clearer evidence risks unfairly judging those involved.