Entertainment news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Your Favorite Coffee Shop Is Probably Streaming Music Illegally. It’s the Music Industry’s Fault, Too (Guest Column)
A Soundtrack survey suggests that music is widely used in US customer-facing businesses, but most are not paying for the licences required for public playback. The guest columnist argues that this deprives creators and rightsholders of income, while the industry’s confusing rules and lack of clear guidance contribute to the problem.
The survey covered 1,525 decision-makers responsible for nearly 15,000 locations across 10 industries. It found that 97% play music for customers, 79% use consumer streaming accounts, and 81% misuse music despite 78% believing they comply; only 5% hold licences from all four US performing rights organisations. The article estimates proper licensing could increase annual business music spending by about $1.4 billion, and says education and simpler options should come before lawsuits.
In short
- Most surveyed US businesses play music without the required licences.
- Confusing rules leave many owners mistakenly confident they comply.
- Proper licensing could add an estimated $1.4 billion in annual spending.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Businesses that play music for customers should pay for the required licences: public playback uses creators’ work to improve a commercial setting, and licensing helps ensure songwriters and rightsholders are compensated. The scale of apparent non-payment suggests meaningful lost income, so clearer education and simpler licensing options could help businesses comply without relying first on litigation.
The case against
Many businesses may reasonably struggle to comply when licensing rules are fragmented across several organisations and guidance is confusing; the survey’s finding that most respondents believe they are compliant supports concern about an information gap, not necessarily deliberate evasion. Requiring multiple licences can also impose costs and administrative work, particularly on small operators, so the industry should make compliance straightforward and proportionate before treating widespread misuse chiefly as a matter for enforcement.
Explained simply
Businesses that play recorded music for customers in the United States generally need permission to do so in public. The rights are managed by performing rights organisations, which collect fees and pass royalties to songwriters, composers and music publishers.
Consumer streaming accounts are usually licensed for personal listening, so using them in a café or shop may not cover public playback. The rules can be hard for businesses to navigate because different organisations represent different music rights.
The issue affects both businesses and music creators: unpaid use can mean lost royalties, while unclear requirements can make it difficult for owners to know what they need. The debate is over how to make licensing easier to understand and obtain, alongside enforcing the rules.
Entertainment Music Research Science TV